News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Sunny
79°
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics

'It was terrible.' Port Jefferson athlete students disappointed after high school drops football team

The team did not meet the required 16-person minimum and are trying to find solutions.

Jenna Rae Gaertner

Aug 30, 2026, 10:12 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

This school year would have marked the 100th year anniversary of the Port Jefferson High School football team, but now the athletes may not get to play at all.

The team learned last week that they won’t have enough players to have an official team this year.

“It was terrible,” said junior Sam Fabian. “I have aspirations of playing college football and continuing that on to the next level. And hearing that the most important year for my football recruitment got shot down was terrible.”

Officials say they expected 23 returning players and eight incoming freshmen.

However, some kids were injured, moved schools or changed sports. Now they only have 11 players. That means they don’t meet the required 16 players minimum.

“We know there's so much statistics about children who play sports and what it gives them in terms of their mental health, their social aspects, the increase in academics,” said Superintendent Jessica Schmettan. “So that's really what's important right now is getting these boys on the field.”

The school went to Section XI, the governing body for Suffolk high school athletics and proposed a merge with the Rocky Point team.

But Section XI did not approve the request, saying it would disqualify Rocky Point from any post-season games. Now the school is appealing the decision in hopes of getting their players on the field.

Section XI said they had no new information as of Sunday night, but added that they did not deny the merger with Rocky Point. They stated that Rocky Point denied combining with Port Jefferson themselves.

Top Stories

01:00
Screenshot 2026-09-08 051018

Rotted utility pole blamed for Chester fire leaving businesses left without power

01:24
F P2 PM 1

Midweek warm-up gives way to more seasonal, sunny days ahead

00:19
plane crash

Yonkers pilot escapes injury after rough plane landing at Westchester County Airport

00:33
fallvaccines0908_2026-09-08-17-07-06

Researchers remind community to receive vaccines this fall

00:29
RTREGWCHVPitBullApttackSG001

Dog owner issued summonses following incident involving bull terrier in Tuckahoe

01:04
Screenshot 2026-09-08 163531

Rockland native Welles Crowther posthumously awarded Presidential Medal of Freedom

01:23
RTREGBXBKHighHolidaysSafetyGThompson4pm_2026-09-08-16-55-03

New York announces increased security ahead of Jewish holidays

00:20
Screenshot 2026-09-08 051227

Lake Carmel house fire leaves firefighter injured and 2 cats dead

00:36
LIBAYSHORE9826_2026-09-08-12-30-23

Made Fresh Salads recalled due to possible listeria contamination

02:12
982026WCmelaniefilm_2026-09-08-05-20-51

Resilience in aftermath of 9/11: Pleasantville woman produces film honoring husband, widows of NY firefighters

00:23
Fatal Fiery Car Crash Monroe

Woman killed in fiery single-car crash in Monroe

02:34
972026WCttt_2026-09-07-07-16-37

'9/11 didn't end on 9/11.' Civilian cancers now outpace first responders

00:49
Screenshot 2026-09-07 115228

Fresh cuts, fresh start: New Rochelle kids get free back-to-school haircuts

01:59
MTHV Made In 0907_2026-09-07-19-52-08

Made in the Hudson Valley: Westchester County woman shares her passion for baking through Baked After Midnight

02:16
RGNPauliesPushKK_2026-09-07-18-21-46

Retired flight attendant retraces path to Ground Zero in memory of lost colleagues

00:42
RGNCommunityBBQKK_2026-09-07-18-29-02

St. Thomas Mar Thoma Church gives back at annual Labor Day barbecue

02:07
972026WCjulia911_2026-09-07-07-14-21

Remembering 25 years ago at the 9/11 Memorial and Museum

01:35
Butterfly Rescue MS 1008_2025-10-08-17-18-43

Plant THESE in your butterfly garden in September (They are irresistible to pollinators!)

01:49
972026LItennis_2026-09-07-06-31-16

From the stands to the court: US Open fans get chance to play tennis

01:30
972026LIcostof_2026-09-07-06-30-57

The Cost Of: Renting vs. Owning

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices