News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics

Westchester County community coming together in wake of 'shocking' tragedy involving beloved teacher

Neighbors in a heartbroken community of Yonkers are leaning on each other for support. It's in the wake of an apparent murder-suicide between a retired police officer and his wife, a beloved Eastchester teacher.

Melanie Palmer

Oct 17, 2024, 9:24 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Neighbors in a heartbroken community of Yonkers are leaning on each other for support. It's in the wake of an apparent murder suicide between a retired police officer and his wife, a beloved Eastchester teacher.

A special Mass was held Thursday evening at the Annunciation Church in Yonkers. It was aimed at helping those impacted by this deeply shocking tragedy.

"A lot of my friends are related to them. It's just devastating, so devastating," says Brian Walsh, who lives down the street.

It happened early Wednesday morning at the family's home on Chittenden Avenue. Police say retired New York City Police officer, Sean O'Neill shot and killed his wife, Arlene. Then, he turned the gun on himself, according to police.

Arlene was a beloved teacher at Anne Hutchinson School. Family, friends, neighbors and the people she worked with are devastated.

An Eastchester mental health expert says getting through this kind of traumatic event is difficult, especially for children.

"You want to do what's best for you and your family during this time. If someone wants to go to religious services, go to that. If someone wants to go to the memorial services, do that as well. For children, ask them if they want to go, I wouldn't force it," says Dr. Angela Reiter.

The O'Neill's have three kids of their own. They're 11, 13, and 15 years old. They were home when this tragedy happened. They weren't physically hurt, according to officers.

A GoFundMe page has been set up to help those kids. It has already raised more than $200,000.

The Eastchester Board of Education has released the following statement along with links to resources for the community:

"Our hearts are heavy with the unimaginable tragedy that transpired within our community yesterday. We are all devastated by the tragic loss of Mrs. O’Neill and mourn alongside our fellow community members. Mrs. O’Neill was not just an exceptional teacher but also a cherished member of our community who touched the lives of countless students and colleagues.

We will all miss Arlene very much and will spend many difficult moments grieving her loss. At this challenging time, we ask members of the community to keep Arlene, her three sons, and the rest of her family and friends in their thoughts and prayers.

Our district believes that love and compassion are crucial elements of how we heal the wounds of this tragedy in the days and months ahead. Creating a safe environment for our students, our teachers, and community members will also help in this process. If your child is upset or exhibiting signs of difficulty in coping, then please contact his/her principal, guidance counselor, or teacher.

We have asked our district support team to ensure that access is provided during school hours for support services to everyone in the Eastchester School District family (Resources Below). As a community, we stand together in that effort."

LIST OF RESOURCES:

● The National Association of School Psychologists (NASP) Helping Children Cope With Tragedy

● Child Mind Institute: Helping Children Cope After a Traumatic Event

● National Institute of Mental Health: Helping Children and Adolescents Cope With Traumatic Events

● The 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline: https://988lifeline.org/

● MHA Of Westchester: Get Help Now | MHA

● Mental Health & Addiction Services — The Guidance Center of Westchester

● Community Services & Family Support | The Arc Westchester

More Stories

Top Stories

00:38
Kenneth Andreu, back row with his arms outstretched, on July 28, 2022.  Credit: Dutchess Community College

Dutchess Community College lecturer killed in Adirondacks plane crash

01:39
HV 3

Another heat wave is possible this week as temperatures soar

01:42
WCBlaisehomicideUpdateKK_2026-07-13-17-06-53

Teen pleads not guilty in Saugerties homicide; grandmother says she tried to get him help

01:49
RTWCHVWPRatsFoloLDValle430pm_2026-07-13-16-44-56

The Westchester Republican County Committee rat activity update three months later

01:49
WCMelanieBurglaryKK_2026-07-13-17-00-08

Police investigate burglary at Yonkers family-owned business

01:26
RTWCHVRocklandWeekendViolenceFoloDCaruso5pm_2026-07-13-17-09-52

Spring Valley police release new details in weekend stabbing investigation

00:21
Tree into Highland Mills Home

Massive 200-year-old tree destroys Orange County home leaving family displaced

00:35
soccerbrainhealth0713_2026-07-13-16-51-39

Study: Playing soccer may impact brain health

01:37
Screenshot 2026-07-13 052554

Rockland County violence leaves multiple people injured in overnight shooting and stabbing incidents

02:20
7132026WCTTT_2026-07-13-08-21-42

'Scandalous.' NY congressional leaders take action on habitually late, missing mail

01:49
Screenshot 2026-07-13 052529

Made in the Hudson Valley: Lost Borough Ice Cream brings taste of the world to Yonkers and beyond

00:56
7132026PLEASANTVILLEMUSICFEST_2026-07-13-05-56-04

Pleasantville Music Festival celebrates 20 years as thousands gather for day of music and family fun

00:19
Screenshot 2026-07-13 062318

Summer at the Library: Mount Vernon library offers meals for children throughout the summer

01:24
BXJAYZMADNESS0712_2026-07-12-22-08-09

Fans holding concert tickets report gate closures outside Jay-Z's final Yankee Stadium show

02:09
RTWCHVWPAmerica250CWilkinson4pm_2026-07-12-18-50-05

History comes alive: White Plains celebrates America's 250th anniversary

DEATH INVESTIGATION

Yonkers man dies after being run over by garbage truck in East New York

00:25
WCBailJumperKK_2026-07-12-12-17-01

Brooklyn bail jumper accused of pushing meth in Putnam County gets 4 years in prison

00:18
Lindsey Graham AP

U.S. Sen. Lindsey Graham has died after a brief and unexpected illness, his office says

01:49
RTWCHVWPWorldCupWatchPartyCWilkinson9pm_2026-07-11-21-11-46

Thousands of soccer fans gather in White Plains for FIFA World Cup quarter final matches watch party

01:15
WCHVAmerica250ParadePThompsonSG001

Patriotism on full display at Eastchester parade celebrating nations 250th anniversary

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices