Soap or sanitizer: Which is better?

Disinfecting your hands with soap and sanitizer is critical to prevent the spread of coronavirus, but is one better than the other?

News 12 Staff

Mar 15, 2020, 11:54 AM

Updated 1,527 days ago

Share:

Text by Geoff Bansen, Video by Michelle Divon:
Hand sanitizer and hand washing have been all over the headlines for a week now. In times like these, they are common sense. But is one better than the other?
Yes, says Andrea Love, Immunologist and Microbiologist from Vital Statistics Consulting.
"The coronavirus has a lipid and protein-based envelope that surrounds and protects the virus from having its RNA degraded. This envelope is exactly what it sounds like - a fatty coating. Soap is a detergent, and one property of that is it is able to disrupt fat molecules and disperse them. This is why soap and other detergents clean your greasy stove so well. So, in the case of COVID-19, what happens when soap interacts with this fat-enveloped virus? Exactly the same thing. The soap that you wash your hands with disrupts the virus’ protective coating and demolishes it. It also will dislodge any attached viral particles and wash them down the drain. This is why regular old soap is the best practice!” says Love.
But what makes this different from hand sanitizer?
"Sanitizer doesn't actually clean your hands, which isn't ideal. But it's also OK if you aren't able to get to a sink," says Love.
Photos: Impact from around the world
undefined
 


More from News 12
2:23
Several Hudson Valley schools seek to pierce state tax gap in budget votes

Several Hudson Valley schools seek to pierce state tax gap in budget votes

2:17
Mostly sunny skies and warm temperatures in the Hudson Valley

Mostly sunny skies and warm temperatures in the Hudson Valley

2:41
Made in the Hudson Valley: Jaymark Jewelers continues family legacy, four decades in the making

Made in the Hudson Valley: Jaymark Jewelers continues family legacy, four decades in the making

1:41
County manager: School bus driver dies in collision with another school bus

County manager: School bus driver dies in collision with another school bus

1:35
North Castle police: Officer shoots man who attacked police with knife in Armonk

North Castle police: Officer shoots man who attacked police with knife in Armonk

1:42
Shrub Oak resident: It's only a matter of time until someone is killed on Old Yorktown Road

Shrub Oak resident: It's only a matter of time until someone is killed on Old Yorktown Road

1:56
Remembering Mark Woods: Rockland County reflects on councilman’s life

Remembering Mark Woods: Rockland County reflects on councilman’s life

1:44
Pride event organizers aim to attract more families while preparing for potential disruptions

Pride event organizers aim to attract more families while preparing for potential disruptions

1:45
Catskill EMS workers taken off duty after video shows apparent mistreatment of disabled patient

Catskill EMS workers taken off duty after video shows apparent mistreatment of disabled patient

1:10
Police: Multivehicle crash on Sprain Brook Parkway kills 1

Police: Multivehicle crash on Sprain Brook Parkway kills 1

Woman indicted for fatal hit-and-run that killed 2 people, including man in wheelchair

Woman indicted for fatal hit-and-run that killed 2 people, including man in wheelchair

0:57
Parents of late Pace University student receive award at 2024 commencement ceremony

Parents of late Pace University student receive award at 2024 commencement ceremony

0:21
Officials: 2 hospitalized following head-on collision in Cornwall

Officials: 2 hospitalized following head-on collision in Cornwall

0:49
Saigon Table: New Vietnamese eatery brings healthy fresh food options to Rye

Saigon Table: New Vietnamese eatery brings healthy fresh food options to Rye

0:13
Dominican University in Orangeburg holds 70th annual commencement ceremony

Dominican University in Orangeburg holds 70th annual commencement ceremony

0:22
Police: Westchester patrol car struck by vehicle in Valhalla

Police: Westchester patrol car struck by vehicle in Valhalla

2:16
Israel music festival terror attack survivors share their Oct. 7 experience with New City congregation

Israel music festival terror attack survivors share their Oct. 7 experience with New City congregation

0:48
DEC says it's monitoring oil slick found at Village of Piermont creek

DEC says it's monitoring oil slick found at Village of Piermont creek

0:28
Yonkers police: 32-year-old man stabbed on Stanley Avenue

Yonkers police: 32-year-old man stabbed on Stanley Avenue

2:04
Rep. Mike Lawler launches bid for reelection in Haverstraw

Rep. Mike Lawler launches bid for reelection in Haverstraw