News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files
FIFA World Cup

Political battles over immigration policies ensue as officials say suspect in Somers triple shooting was illegal immigrant

Several officials and candidates have issued press releases stating local and federal immigration policies ultimately allowed Monday's tragedy in Somers to happen.

Ben Nandy

and

Cole McDonnell

Oct 31, 2024, 4:24 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

News about a triple shooting suspect's illegal immigration status has triggered a political campaign by Republicans against federal and local immigration policies and their Democratic opponents.

Several officials and candidates have issued press releases stating the policies ultimately allowed Monday's tragedy in Somers to happen.

A spokesperson for Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) told News 12 Thursday murder suspect Fernando Andres Jimenez Meza has been in the country illegally.

Police said Jimenez shot a woman and her two teenaged sons Monday and fled before being arrested Tuesday in Putnam County.

One of the teens, a high school sophomore, died.

The ICE spokesperson said Border Patrol officers detained Jimenez in 2004 in Tecate, California and that he provided a false name, he falsely claimed he was from Mexico, he was voluntarily deported and he illegally returned at some point.

Jimenez is a Chilean citizen, ICE said.

"I'm against illegal immigration," Yasmin Melo, a neighbor of the victims, said. "Whatever the reasons are for everybody, just wait your turn. I cannot express how angry I am. That's something that should not have happened."

Officials said Jimenez had previously been arrested for at least one offense in Westchester County.

"In this case, the district attorney's office is fully prosecuting this criminal act to the fullest extent of the law," said a spokesperson for the Westchester County government.

Republican officials and candidates immediately began criticizing federal and county immigration policies and their Democratic opponents.

"It happened precisely because Kathy Hochul and Democrats in New York refuse to cooperate with ICE," Rep. Mike Lawler wrote in an email, referencing sanctuary policies which may limit communication with ICE about undocumented immigrants.

Erika Verde, a neighbor who heard the commotion Monday, did not make the same connection Lawler and other Republicans are making.

"Not at all. I don't think so," Verde said. "I mean, that's my opinion. I honestly don't know. I just don't think so."

Catherine Cioffi, communications director for Westchester County Executive George Latimer countered the political statements by Republicans.

"There is not 'sanctuary policy' in Westchester County," she wrote in a text message. "We work cooperatively with ICE. In this case, the District Attorney's office is fully prosecuting this criminal act to the fullest extent of the law. Our commitment has always been to public safety.

More Stories

Top Stories

01:42
WC 5PM_StrangerDanger_ajc_2026-04-21-17-10-08

Mount Kisco parents raise safety concerns after men detained near elementary school during recess

01:56
headlines HV

Showers are here to start Earth Day!

00:18
4222026YONKERSPOLICECRASH_2026-04-22-06-12-45

Two Yonkers police officers injured in crash while responding to burglary call

02:05
Screenshot 2026-04-21 124622

New details revealed on investigation into antisemitic incident at Scarsdale HS

02:36
Screenshot 2026-04-22 052558

The Voice of the Subway: Meet Bernie Wagenblast, the person behind the MTA’s most familiar announcement

01:29
RTWCHVWorldCupBarPermitJHopwood10pm_2026-04-21-22-35-31

World Cup boost for local businesses; ticket prices out of reach for many fans

00:36
RTWCHVSVBodyUpdate04212026VO10pm_2026-04-21-22-11-31

Spring Valley man arrested in connection to body found under truck

01:39
RTWCHVPutnamMurderConvictionBNandy5pm_2026-04-21-17-21-17

Putnam prosecutors' plea deal to suspect in 2008 murder: Admit to minor offense and get out of jail now

01:50
RTWCHVWoodburyCommonRobberiesBGomez5pm_2026-04-21-17-22-06

New video shows suspects ransacking Gucci store during Woodbury Common smash-and-grab

01:34
WC 10P TUES_SVFire_ajc_2026-04-21-22-07-29

Residents displaced after serious house fire in Spring Valley

01:33
RTWCHVTarrytownRatsLDValle5pm_2026-04-21-17-25-01

Residents in Sleepy Hollow Terraced Garden Apartments voice concerns over mold, vermin & more

00:49
4212026DURANRELEASED_2026-04-21-06-00-12

Convicted NYPD sergeant from Mahopac makes bail, released from prison during appeal

00:28
4212026ROCKLANDILLEGALDUMPING_2026-04-21-06-01-14

Driver ticketed after illegal dumping halted at state park in Rockland County

00:17
4212026WCcrash_2026-04-21-05-28-58

Car crashes into sculpture and street light at Ossining intersection

00:30
4212026POUGHKEEPSIEPUBCLOSED_2026-04-21-06-00-44

City police shut down bar, arrest bartenders for underage drinking in Poughkeepsie

01:48
WC 10P MON_Route22Funding_ajc_2026-04-20-22-08-57

Route 22 in ‘critical condition.’ Experts say repairs could cost tens of millions

00:25
marijuana image update

Marijuana use rises among young adult women, annual substance report finds

00:33
4202026WC12blaise_2026-04-20-12-13-02

Cornwall community mourns teen killed in fiery rollover crash on way to work

01:43
WC 10P MON_CareerPathway_ajc_2026-04-20-22-17-22

Westchester County lawmakers pass law to expand access to training in construction

00:41
Yonkers Fire

Detached garage up in flames in Yonkers

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices