Exclusive: Workplace probe finds allegations by 3 women against ex-City of Newburgh police chief ‘not supported’

Chief Anthony Geraci left the department in May for a top security job with Newburgh schools. He says the unfounded accusations are part of a smear campaign.

Blaise Gomez

Jun 17, 2024, 8:49 PM

Updated 28 days ago

Share:

News 12 is learning more about workplace accusations made by three women against the City of Newburgh’s former police chief before he left the department for a job with the school district.
The female department members accuse former Chief Anthony Geraci of gender discrimination, retaliation and creating a hostile work environment.
One woman sums up her complaints in the report by calling him an “arrogant narcissist who has a problem with women.”
Another accuses the former chief of unfairly assigning work and tasks based on gender, like taking notes and cleaning, and claims Geraci retaliated against her by changing her schedule for filing the complaint.
Six other department members, who were both male and female, and Geraci were interviewed during the independent probe which ultimately found in March that the allegations were “not supported.”
Residents News 12 spoke to say both the womens’ claims and the findings are a concern.
“A lot of times when women come forward, they’re telling the truth and if it is true and get away with it, that’s not right,” says Kenneth Hayes.
“I don’t trust the system. The politicians, police chiefs, none of that. I don’t trust them,” says Alonzo Lenier.
Geraci left the department in May for a top security job with Newburgh schools. He says the unfounded accusations are part of a smear campaign.
“This investigation was closed prior to my departure from the police department,” says Geraci. “The fact that unfounded accusations (determined by an independent investigator) are now newsworthy feels retaliatory in an effort to defame my reputation and tarnish my character.”
News 12 received multiple reports of the investigation during the probe, which began last November, but was not able to confirm the information until recently when the internal report was obtained by News 12 through a written request under the Freedom of Information Act.
City officials and the Newburgh Enlarged City School District did not respond to requests for comment.


More from News 12
1:33
HEAT ALERT: Heat advisory continues through Wednesday, evening pop-up storms likely in the Hudson Valley

HEAT ALERT: Heat advisory continues through Wednesday, evening pop-up storms likely in the Hudson Valley

1:21
Lightning strikes tree in Yorktown Heights, causes house fire

Lightning strikes tree in Yorktown Heights, causes house fire

7:10
Trump picks Sen. JD Vance of Ohio, a once-fierce critic turned loyal ally, as his GOP running mate

Trump picks Sen. JD Vance of Ohio, a once-fierce critic turned loyal ally, as his GOP running mate

1:36
43 sick cats rescued from scorching hot van in Newburgh

43 sick cats rescued from scorching hot van in Newburgh

1:35
Port Jervis summer camp program on pause due to extreme heat

Port Jervis summer camp program on pause due to extreme heat

1:48
Meals on Wheels of Rockland keeps seniors fed and cool during hot summer

Meals on Wheels of Rockland keeps seniors fed and cool during hot summer

1:52
Popular high-powered rifle used in Trump rally shooting

Popular high-powered rifle used in Trump rally shooting

1:25
Staying cool amid intense heat at Tibbetts Brook Park

Staying cool amid intense heat at Tibbetts Brook Park

Heat Alert: Energy companies urge conservation as temperatures soar

Heat Alert: Energy companies urge conservation as temperatures soar

0:43
MTA outlines plan to keep riders cool during intense heat and humidity

MTA outlines plan to keep riders cool during intense heat and humidity

2:58
INTERVIEWS: Local Hudson Valley leaders discuss assassination attempt of former President Trump

INTERVIEWS: Local Hudson Valley leaders discuss assassination attempt of former President Trump

2:14
Don't be caught in the dark: Are you ready to power through hurricane season?

Don't be caught in the dark: Are you ready to power through hurricane season?

3:30
Trump heads to convention as authorities investigate motive, security in assassination attempt

Trump heads to convention as authorities investigate motive, security in assassination attempt

5:30
In prime-time address, Biden warns of election-year rhetoric, saying ‘it’s time to cool it down’

In prime-time address, Biden warns of election-year rhetoric, saying ‘it’s time to cool it down’

1:40
Chappaqua reacts to assassination attempt on former President Trump

Chappaqua reacts to assassination attempt on former President Trump

1:54
Reps. Lawler, Torres to introduce bill enhancing Secret Service protection for presidential candidates

Reps. Lawler, Torres to introduce bill enhancing Secret Service protection for presidential candidates

2:07
A look back at US political violence that changed history

A look back at US political violence that changed history

2:31
Pace professor weighs political rhetoric, gun control in wake of Trump rally shooting

Pace professor weighs political rhetoric, gun control in wake of Trump rally shooting

4:10
EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW: Trump rally attendee gives his eyewitness account of the shooting

EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW: Trump rally attendee gives his eyewitness account of the shooting

2:37
Security increased at Trump Tower following rally shooting

Security increased at Trump Tower following rally shooting