News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files

Yorktown Town Board votes to deny application for local historical designation of Underhill Farm property

On Tuesday night, the Yorktown town board denied a local historical designation application of nearby Underhill Farm property citing financial reasons and their own efforts to protect it.

Diane Caruso

Feb 6, 2024, 5:19 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

On Tuesday night, the Yorktown town board denied a local historical designation application for the Underhill Farm property, citing financial reasons and its own efforts to protect it.

Yorktown Heritage Preservation Commission is pushing for Underhill Farm to be designated as a historic landmark.

Underhill Farm, located at 370 Underhill Ave. has deep roots in Yorktown dating back to the 18th century.

The Yorktown Planning Board approved a resolution in July that would allow the sites use as a residential community for seniors.


The approved project involves the construction of 48 townhouses, a 32-unit condominium building and a mixed-use building consisting of 68 apartments.

Project developers argue the call to landmark Underhill Farm as “historically significant” may hinder their financial goals.

Tuesday night's resolution states that the property owner has seven days to agree to this detail. The town board would need to approve the mansion being demolished in the future.

Also during the meeting, it was noted that there are lawyers figuring out a way to protect the mansion at 370 Underhill Ave. in perpetuity. 

After Tuesday’s vote, News 12 heard from those who were fighting to landmark it locally.

They say they are disappointed in the outcome and reiterated that they wanted to work in collaboration with the developer to protect the town's treasure. 

More Stories

Top Stories

00:32
415BXTRAINSHOOTINGFIX_2026-04-15-08-25-10

Attacker on run after shooting man aboard Bronx train

01:52
record heat possible bx

Record-breaking heat possible in The Bronx today with a chance of rain

01:24
415HOCHULTAXPROPOSALNOON_2026-04-15-12-15-07

Governor proposes second homeowners in NYC to pay extra taxes

AP26105587936686

Popular NYC SantaCon charity fundraiser was more con than Claus, authorities say

Chris Wright

U.S. energy secretary addresses rising gas prices and tri‑state energy challenges in exclusive interview

AP26105688281469

Jury finds that Ticketmaster and Live Nation had an anticompetitive monopoly over big concert venues

02:25
12PMACHETE IN LAW EXCLUSIVE ST_2026-04-12-12-34-59

Close friends of man accused in Grand Central stabbings say 'He was going through a lot mentally'

01:35
32bjstrikelookaheadCM_2026-04-14-17-28-56

NYC building service workers to vote on strike that could impact 1.5M residents

01:17
415brittanynoon_2026-04-15-12-03-56

Bronxites get a taste of summer; record breaking temps possible today

00:21
415motthavenrobbery_2026-04-15-06-21-10

2 wanted for stealing man’s wallet in violent Mott Haven robbery

01:44
415gregtrafficlight_2026-04-15-05-16-51

Red light or green light? Neighborhood split on new traffic light in Fordham

01:35
IMG 7765

How to find deer-resistant plants & keep deer out of your garden for good

01:40
fishingsznCM_2026-04-14-22-28-12

Fishing fever: Warm weather brings fishers to City Island for the big catch

01:22
7bb683e9-4a2d-422d-bf18-f0c7433b73d7

Record-breaking heat expected across the tri-state Wednesday

01:51
Wright

Exclusive: Energy Secretary Chris Wright discusses the future of tri-state power, gas prices and the AI surge

01:12
BXSUBWAYSNATCHERUPDATE415265A_2026-04-15-06-08-36

Police release photos of subway chain snatcher in Mount Hope

00:36
chainsnatchingspree5pZC_2026-04-14-17-05-05

Moped-riding duo wanted for chain snatching spree

01:32
WATERMAINBREAK2AB_2026-04-14-17-21-17

‘Like I'm in a river.’ Water line leak floods streets in Soundview

01:56
5PCITY RUN GROCERY STORE PRESSERst_2026-04-14-17-37-20

Mamdani announces plans for 5 city-run grocery stores

03:07
BXBK5PMHEATHERAOC_2026-04-14-17-21-17

Exclusive: Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez tours Port Morris site to revitalize waterfront

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices