News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files

Teen accused of killing ex-girlfriend in Nesconset arraigned on murder charge

Austin Lynch, 18, of Nesconset, has been indicted by a Suffolk County grand jury on a second-degree murder charge in the death of 19-year-old Emily Finn.

Daniella Rodriguez

Dec 4, 2025, 10:16 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

An 18-year-old accused of fatally shooting his ex-girlfriend in Nesconset appeared before a judge for the first time Thursday, as prosecutors detailed a disturbing timeline leading up to the killing.

Austin Lynch, 18, of Nesconset, has been indicted by a Suffolk County grand jury on a second-degree murder charge in the death of 19-year-old Emily Finn. Prosecutors say the two had dated for about three years and that Finn had returned home for Thanksgiving break when the shooting happened.

Lynch entered the packed courtroom without showing emotion. A large bandage covered part of his forehead, and a portion of his nose appeared to be missing from what authorities say was a self-inflicted gunshot wound. Finn’s family and friends, many dressed in pink, filled the courtroom, some crying as prosecutors recounted the events.

According to prosecutors, Finn went to Lynch’s home on the morning of Nov. 26 hoping for closure after their recent breakup. Minutes later, Lynch’s parents told investigators they heard gunshots. Prosecutors say Lynch used a family-owned semi-automatic shotgun to shoot Finn in the head before attempting to take his own life.

In court, prosecutors also said Lynch had been trying persistently to contact Finn after the breakup and had previously threatened suicide.

They cited a note found in his phone six days before the death, in which he wrote that he intended to “leave this place before my 18th birthday” and included explicit language stating he hated her.

Lynch is being held without bail and is expected back in court Monday in Riverhead.

The Long Island Against Domestic Violence tells News 12 if you or someone you know is in a domestic violence situation, to call their hotline at 631-666-8833.

More Stories

Top Stories

00:28
5192026I287VANFIRE2_2026-05-19-06-05-18

Flames engulf van and burning fuel spreads across roadway on I-287 in Westchester

01:52
Heat alert and futurecast HV

Heat Alert: it is a "Summer Sizzler" out today with a spotty afternoon storm

01:28
PLANE INCIDENT

Flight school aircraft overturns after takeoff in West Harrison

02:22
Screenshot 2026-05-19 062035

Irvington EV charging plan sparks pushback from residents

00:40
0516fatalax_2026-05-16-13-33-46

State troopers identify person killed in 3-vehicle crash on Bear Mountain State Parkway

00:17
5182026CARINTOLAKECARMEL_2026-05-18-05-38-45

Car goes into Lake Carmel, driver makes it out safely

01:30
5192026LItoys_2026-05-19-05-27-47

STEM toys aim to keep kids learning and engaged over summer break

00:23
Trump

President Donald Trump to visit Hudson Valley this week

02:11
WC 5PM MON_DoorDashShooterClosingCase_ajc_2026-03-23-17-10-24

Shooter of lost DoorDash driver sentenced to 17 years in prison

01:46
WCHVAccusedDogKillerSG001

Opening statements begin in trial of man accused of killing small dog by throwing it into the street

01:41
RTWCHVMVRacistGraffitiJNash430pm_2026-05-18-16-47-22

Racist graffiti found at Mount Vernon school

01:37
RTWCHVRocklandLettersWLoveDCaruso430pm_2026-05-18-16-50-45

Rockland high school students spread kindness through 'Letters with Love'

01:31
Screenshot 2026-05-18 053939

Historic bath houses reopen at Oakland Beach ahead of holiday and as summer weather arrives

02:02
Screenshot 2026-05-18 070258

Made in the Hudson Valley: Man spends 30-plus years sharing family's Italian culture through Tuscana Pasta Co.

01:50
5182026WCthecost_2026-05-18-08-09-28

The Cost Of: Cars

00:25
0517sprainbrookfatalax_2026-05-17-12-08-27

One person dead in Sprain Brook Parkway crash

02:15
5182026WCflappy_2026-05-18-07-00-10

Lake Peekskill mother with autism turns to art to cope with cancer diagnosis and inspire others

01:50
RTWCHVLorraineHansberryNameCWilkinson4pm_2026-05-17-16-14-50

Lorraine Hansberry Way: Renowned Croton playwright honored with street renaming 

02:29
RTWCHVEliotEngelMemorialCWilkinson10pm_2026-05-17-22-11-26

Memorial service honoring former U.S. Rep. Eliot Engel held at Lehman College

01:49
WCMIRACLELEAGUESOFTBALLGAME05174P_2026-05-17-16-36-54

Miracle League baseball game highlights inclusion and community in Westchester

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices