NY Supreme Court judge to decide legal battle between Orangetown, hotel planning to house migrants

Officials want an injunction to be issued to ensure the Armoni Inn and Suites can only be used as a hotel and not as a shelter run by New York City. 

Diane Caruso and Lee Danuff

May 31, 2023, 9:19 PM

Updated 320 days ago

Share:

A state Supreme Court judge in Rockland County will make a decision soon involving a legal battle between Orangetown and a hotel that planned to take in migrants.
Officials want an injunction to be issued to ensure the Armoni Inn and Suites can only be used as a hotel and not as a shelter run by New York City. 
Todd Soloway, on behalf of the Armoni Inn & Suites, stated Orangetown's application of local law is unconstitutional and believes there are political motives behind enforcement, citing statements made by the Orangetown supervisor on Fox News. 
Robert Zitt, a lawyer for the Town of Orangetown, says that the town is looking to maintain local zoning laws.  
"This is not about politicians. This is not about politics. This is a local issue," says Zitt.  "I urge the parties to meet and converse to try and come up with an organized resolution for all of those impacted," said Judge Christie D’Alessio.
Ultimately, D'alessio said she will have a written decision in the coming weeks regarding an injunction against the hotel.
Until then, the temporary restraining order issued earlier this month to stop the Armoni Inn from being used to house migrants will stay in place.
The hotel has been closed for weeks.There will be a virtual hearing Thursday regarding efforts by the hotel to reopen.


More from News 12
2:54
Prison conversations shed light on Robert Durst's mental state, depths he went to evade justice

Prison conversations shed light on Robert Durst's mental state, depths he went to evade justice

2:07
Terrific Tuesday with sunny skies in the Hudson Valley

Terrific Tuesday with sunny skies in the Hudson Valley

1:55
Gov. Hochul, state lawmakers reach 'conceptual' agreement on state budget

Gov. Hochul, state lawmakers reach 'conceptual' agreement on state budget

0:35
Police: 41-year-old man recovering from stabbing at New Rochelle sports lounge

Police: 41-year-old man recovering from stabbing at New Rochelle sports lounge

New DMV comes to downtown Port Jervis

New DMV comes to downtown Port Jervis

2:12
Rockland pressures Evergreen Court to clean up 2021 fire site

Rockland pressures Evergreen Court to clean up 2021 fire site

1:54
What happens to the clothes you donate? Greenburgh town supervisor explains

What happens to the clothes you donate? Greenburgh town supervisor explains

1:59
Fire engulfs 3 cars at Port Chester's The Waterfront shopping complex

Fire engulfs 3 cars at Port Chester's The Waterfront shopping complex

1:42
South Blooming Grove issued DOH violations amid water crisis and construction boom

South Blooming Grove issued DOH violations amid water crisis and construction boom

1:52
15 protesters arrested, blocked traffic on Newburgh-Beacon Bridge during Monday rush hour

15 protesters arrested, blocked traffic on Newburgh-Beacon Bridge during Monday rush hour

0:28
Wawayanda town officials search for answers on vandalized park

Wawayanda town officials search for answers on vandalized park

0:24
Stepinac basketball star up for grabs after decommitting from University of Kentucky

Stepinac basketball star up for grabs after decommitting from University of Kentucky

0:49
‘I need your help.’ Parents of missing Sullivan County woman plead for public’s help to solve cold case

‘I need your help.’ Parents of missing Sullivan County woman plead for public’s help to solve cold case

0:37
State police search for missing woman with brain injury in Westchester County

State police search for missing woman with brain injury in Westchester County

0:56
Police: Greenburgh pedestrian struck by car at intersection, remains in critical condition

Police: Greenburgh pedestrian struck by car at intersection, remains in critical condition

0:25
Irvington Girl Scouts celebrate 100 years of scouting with luncheon and fashion show

Irvington Girl Scouts celebrate 100 years of scouting with luncheon and fashion show

0:40
Hudson Valley police departments increase patrols around religious sites following aerial attack

Hudson Valley police departments increase patrols around religious sites following aerial attack

0:29
‘My Daddy Loves Me’: Father and son read their new book at Yonkers library

‘My Daddy Loves Me’: Father and son read their new book at Yonkers library

Vote 2024: Ask your questions for Congressional District 16 Democratic candidates

Vote 2024: Ask your questions for Congressional District 16 Democratic candidates

0:32
Plans for migrant children shelter in Mount Pleasant put on hold by state Supreme Court

Plans for migrant children shelter in Mount Pleasant put on hold by state Supreme Court