Friend of woman convicted of mom's murder faces jury

Closing arguments were made Thursday in the trial of Carmela Magnetti, accused of helping to plot and cover up the murder of her best friend's mother. The jury began deliberating at 1:00 p.m., and the

News 12 Staff

Aug 29, 2008, 5:10 PM

Updated 5,796 days ago

Share:

Closing arguments were made Thursday in the trial of Carmela Magnetti, accused of helping to plot and cover up the murder of her best friend's mother.
The jury began deliberating at 1:00 p.m., and the 12 members of the jury sent the judge several notes, requesting to see crime scene evidence and photos, as well as cell phone records.
Magnetti?s friend, Anna Trovato, has already been convicted of second-degree murder for stabbing her mother, Patricia Mery, 24 times with a kitchen knife and then hitting her with a baseball bat on Mother's Day in 2006.
At the time of the murder, Trovato and her mother were locked in a battle over the custody of Trovato?s daughter, Arianna.
Trovato testified Tuesday, defending her best friend and blaming Magnetti's cousin Arthur Walsh for her mother's death.
In the closing arguments of the Magentti trial, the prosecution said Magnetti played a key role in the crime, concocting an alibi for herself and Trovato.
The prosecutors also said Magentti was the one who drove Trovato to her mother?s Ossining house, knowing she intended to kill Mery, and later Magnetti helped her friend clean the crime scene with bleach and destroy bloody evidence.
But Magnetti?s attorneys said the prosecution?s case is rooted in fantasy and sloppy police work, and that police ?want to wrap up the case quickly and put a bow on it.? The defense claims that the real murderer is still on the loose.
If convicted, Magnetti could spend the next 15 years in prison.


More from News 12
1:55
STORM WATCH: Mostly comfortable weekend mixed in with possible storms in the Hudson Valley

STORM WATCH: Mostly comfortable weekend mixed in with possible storms in the Hudson Valley

1:55
NYPD: 3-year-old fatally struck in Harlem was from New Rochelle

NYPD: 3-year-old fatally struck in Harlem was from New Rochelle

0:30
Wake services held for Port Chester police officer killed in an off-duty motorbike crash

Wake services held for Port Chester police officer killed in an off-duty motorbike crash

0:25
Police: Newburgh man faces prison time for menacing Maybrook residents with gun

Police: Newburgh man faces prison time for menacing Maybrook residents with gun

1:49
2 'underperforming' Stop & Shop stores in Hudson Valley set to close

2 'underperforming' Stop & Shop stores in Hudson Valley set to close

0:34
Testimony ends in Westchester nonprofit's lawsuit filed against Lyft over wheelchair access

Testimony ends in Westchester nonprofit's lawsuit filed against Lyft over wheelchair access

0:57
Nearly $5 million to go toward clean water efforts, police departments in Westchester

Nearly $5 million to go toward clean water efforts, police departments in Westchester

2:10
How to spot scams, fake listings on Amazon Prime Day 2024

How to spot scams, fake listings on Amazon Prime Day 2024

0:26
Police: Bronx man charged in Carmel domestic disturbance

Police: Bronx man charged in Carmel domestic disturbance

1:40
Lawmakers try to force action from state as more beaches close due to bacteria levels

Lawmakers try to force action from state as more beaches close due to bacteria levels

1:03
‘Like a bee colony.’ Crews work to finish preparations for Pleasantville Music Festival

‘Like a bee colony.’ Crews work to finish preparations for Pleasantville Music Festival

1:32
Owners of decades-old restaurant in Rockland County explain reasons for closure

Owners of decades-old restaurant in Rockland County explain reasons for closure

0:57
Congers Fire Department Carnival returns for first time since COVID

Congers Fire Department Carnival returns for first time since COVID

0:24
Rockland County officials warn of contractor scams targeting homeowners

Rockland County officials warn of contractor scams targeting homeowners

0:24
Ulster County offers refunds to season pass holders following pool closure

Ulster County offers refunds to season pass holders following pool closure

0:29
Sen. Michelle Hinchey secures $1 million in funding for Hudson Valley Research Laboratory

Sen. Michelle Hinchey secures $1 million in funding for Hudson Valley Research Laboratory

0:17
New Rochelle firefighters rescue fawn stuck in muddy pond

New Rochelle firefighters rescue fawn stuck in muddy pond

1:52
Hudson Valley voters react to President Biden's press conference, state of presidential race

Hudson Valley voters react to President Biden's press conference, state of presidential race

1:43
Rye Brook family raises money for therapy pool

Rye Brook family raises money for therapy pool

1:12
Kidney donor needed for Westchester County toddler

Kidney donor needed for Westchester County toddler