'It is discrimination by the pen.' Advocates worry Brookhaven's redistricting proposal could weaken vote from Black and brown communities

The council district maps have to change because populations shifted when the census was counted in 2020.

News 12 Staff

Sep 29, 2022, 12:29 AM

Updated 572 days ago

Share:

Some advocates are concerned proposed changes to the Town of Brookhaven's council districts could weaken the minority vote.
The council district maps have to change because populations shifted when the census was counted in 2020.
One of the districts will get larger while the other will get smaller.
Districts 2 and 6 are the ones that need to change. However, District 4, which contains some predominantly Black and brown communities would extend northeast into Ridge, a mostly white community.
That would cause the vote for those communities to be weakened, according to some in the area.
"It is discrimination by the pen," says Brookhaven Town NAACP President Georgette Grier-Key.
She says the two areas are completely different if you look at the socio-economics, which is the classic case for gerrymandering. Grier-Key says District 2 should be larger and District 6 should be smaller.
"We don't want council districts based on race - we want council districts based on communities," Grier-Key says.
The town is pushing against that criticism.
A Brookhaven town spokesperson says the redistricting is a fair, open and transparent process that unifies many neighborhoods that have been split by previous plans.
In a statement, the town spokesperson wrote, "The map before the town board on Thursday makes no changes for more than 90% of residents...The redistricting process conducted by Brookhaven was fair, open and transparent, with more than a dozen public hearings..."
It is possible that the town council will vote on the proposed districts on Thursday. The board has until Dec. 15 to choose a new map and those boundaries will remain in effect for the next decade.


More from News 12
0:36
Wake and funeral announced for Westchester correction officer killed in crash

Wake and funeral announced for Westchester correction officer killed in crash

2:04
Sunny in the 60s today, light showers expected tomorrow morning

Sunny in the 60s today, light showers expected tomorrow morning

3:07
Unconscious woman rescued from Spring Valley apartment complex fire; firefighter injured

Unconscious woman rescued from Spring Valley apartment complex fire; firefighter injured

0:20
3 Hudson Valley small towns ranked among best places for retirement

3 Hudson Valley small towns ranked among best places for retirement

Vote 2024: Ask your questions for Congressional District 16 Democratic candidates

Vote 2024: Ask your questions for Congressional District 16 Democratic candidates

0:32
Naming contest announced for baby falcons on Mario M. Cuomo Bridge

Naming contest announced for baby falcons on Mario M. Cuomo Bridge

0:56
Headlines: 2 men from Orange County sentenced for drug dealing, Ulster County drug and weapon bust

Headlines: 2 men from Orange County sentenced for drug dealing, Ulster County drug and weapon bust

0:42
State DEC introduces new shark handling regulations for marine anglers

State DEC introduces new shark handling regulations for marine anglers

0:36
Rockland County road resurfacing program begins

Rockland County road resurfacing program begins

0:22
Authorities: Man and woman arrested in Westchester for attempted homicide and assault

Authorities: Man and woman arrested in Westchester for attempted homicide and assault

0:40
Former Spring Valley building inspector files federal lawsuit against Rockland County and DA's office

Former Spring Valley building inspector files federal lawsuit against Rockland County and DA's office

0:24
New gastropub The Governess set to open on Poughkeepsie's waterfront

New gastropub The Governess set to open on Poughkeepsie's waterfront

0:36
Traffic Alert: Main Street closure in Kingston for roadwork

Traffic Alert: Main Street closure in Kingston for roadwork

0:48
9 steps to take if your ‘fur-ever’ friend goes missing

9 steps to take if your ‘fur-ever’ friend goes missing

0:31
President Joe Biden to visit Village of Irvington for celebrity fundraiser

President Joe Biden to visit Village of Irvington for celebrity fundraiser

2:39
Mary J. Blige’s Road to the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame started in Yonkers public housing

Mary J. Blige’s Road to the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame started in Yonkers public housing

2:04
‘She wore her uniform proudly.’ Westchester COBA mourns late officer Eleanor Birrittella

‘She wore her uniform proudly.’ Westchester COBA mourns late officer Eleanor Birrittella

1:45
West Point’s Keller Army Hospital, Hudson Valley VA form partnership to expand access

West Point’s Keller Army Hospital, Hudson Valley VA form partnership to expand access

2:19
Turn to Tara team looks at new domestic violence laws implemented across tri-state following NJ murder-suicide

Turn to Tara team looks at new domestic violence laws implemented across tri-state following NJ murder-suicide

1:56
Armonk twins showcase baking skills for Passover

Armonk twins showcase baking skills for Passover