Man on parole for murder of Pearl River teen back behind bars

Richard LaBarbera allegedly violated the conditions of his parole and is being held at the Erie County Jail.

News 12 Staff

Jul 26, 2019, 2:53 AM

Updated 1,740 days ago

Share:

Less than a month after being released from prison, a man who served nearly 40 years for killing a Pearl River girl is back behind bars.

Richard LaBarbera allegedly violated the conditions of his parole and is being held at the Erie County Jail.

LaBarbera was released from Sing Sing Prison on July 8., and as a condition of his parole, he was sent to Erie County.

His release sparked outrage from Pearl River residents who launched an effort to keep the convicted killer behind bars for life.
LaBarbera and Robert McCain were both convicted back in the 1980s of brutally murdering 16-year-old Paula Bohovesky as she walked home from her job at the Pearl River Library.

John Murphy, whose daughter was friends with Bohovesky, has been fighting for years to make sure the two men were kept in prison.

"We believe it was a heinous crime committed by a thoroughly worthless, moral-less, dangerous criminal and he just doesn't belong in the general population," Murphy says.

McCain was denied his parole last month. It was not immediately clear which parole conditions LaBarbera violated. Officials tell News 12 he is scheduled for a hearing to address his violations.

Both LaBarbera and McCain were sentenced to 25 years to life for the murder.

Rockland County Executive Ed Day released a statement thanking the parole officers and condemning the state Parole Board for releasing him. It says in part: "Not surprisingly, it only took him days to run afoul of the law. I remind all that this cretin was on parole when he murdered Paula so he clearly has learned nothing other than how to be a scar on society. He committed murder, a crime of permanency, and should be permanently in jail."
 


More from News 12
2:05
Make-A-Wish grants 12-year-old from Peekskill dream of becoming a chef

Make-A-Wish grants 12-year-old from Peekskill dream of becoming a chef

2:26
Mild, isolated shower overnight before mostly cloudy Tuesday in the Hudson Valley

Mild, isolated shower overnight before mostly cloudy Tuesday in the Hudson Valley

1:56
Former Somers HS coach throws 1st pitch at opening game following virus that nearly killed him

Former Somers HS coach throws 1st pitch at opening game following virus that nearly killed him

2:00
Staff delicately salvage 200-year-old relics following ceiling collapse at Boscobel House

Staff delicately salvage 200-year-old relics following ceiling collapse at Boscobel House

1:23
Tractor-trailer was left teetering after crash on Bear Mountain Bridge Road

Tractor-trailer was left teetering after crash on Bear Mountain Bridge Road

2:59
2 defendants in body parts case plead not guilty to second-degree murder charges

2 defendants in body parts case plead not guilty to second-degree murder charges

0:41
 Congers celebrates 2-year-old with terminal brain cancer halfway to Halloween

Congers celebrates 2-year-old with terminal brain cancer halfway to Halloween

Westchester Police Emergency Service Unit conducts special training at closed Galleria Mall

Westchester Police Emergency Service Unit conducts special training at closed Galleria Mall

0:31
Orange County teachers in the running to be named ‘America’s Favorite Teacher’

Orange County teachers in the running to be named ‘America’s Favorite Teacher’

0:28
Gas leak at East Fishkill’s Amazon warehouse prompted employee evacuation

Gas leak at East Fishkill’s Amazon warehouse prompted employee evacuation

0:13
Sheriff: Windows shattered in Hopewell Junction bus crash, no major injuries

Sheriff: Windows shattered in Hopewell Junction bus crash, no major injuries

1:03
Pelham Manor man pleads guilty in health care fraud and kickback scheme

Pelham Manor man pleads guilty in health care fraud and kickback scheme

1:53
Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

0:39
Sean 'Diddy' Combs files motion to dismiss some claims in a sexual assault lawsuit

Sean 'Diddy' Combs files motion to dismiss some claims in a sexual assault lawsuit

2:02
Traffic Alert: Gas line work in Tarrytown to affect roads for the next 3 to 4 weeks

Traffic Alert: Gas line work in Tarrytown to affect roads for the next 3 to 4 weeks

0:54
Headlines: Mamaroneck home burglary, shots fired in Poughkeepsie, kayaker rescued

Headlines: Mamaroneck home burglary, shots fired in Poughkeepsie, kayaker rescued

0:18
Yonkers police launch 'Family Police Initiative' to strengthen community bonds

Yonkers police launch 'Family Police Initiative' to strengthen community bonds

0:23
Sorority recognized for nurturing community and environment

Sorority recognized for nurturing community and environment

0:41
Vote Now: Help choose the next cover model for DEC's Habitat & Access stamp

Vote Now: Help choose the next cover model for DEC's Habitat & Access stamp