News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Sunny
55°
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics

Westchester County legislator wants Rep. Lawler to apologize to community over comments on citizenship status

Controversy is brewing over comments made by Rep. Mike Lawler on a Westchester County legislator's citizenship status.

Melanie Palmer

•

Feb 19, 2025, 10:15 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Controversy is brewing over comments made by Rep. Mike Lawler on a Westchester County legislator's citizenship status.

It happened during the Westchester County Board of Legislators meeting Tuesday afternoon.

The meeting was with the federal delegation, and Rep. Lawler was there.

"I prompted the question, as the way I look, and if I'm ever approached by ICE, what should I produce as documentation?," asked Westchester County Board of Legislators Vice Chair José Alvarado.

"Like every other person that is engaged by law enforcement, if you are asked for information, cooperate. I wouldn't expect you as a, I assume you are a citizen, maybe you're not, maybe you are but...," Lawler responded.

Alvarado, who is a U.S. citizen, says Lawler's response left him appalled and some other members of the board shocked.

"What is his right to question another duly elected official, high-ranking duly elected official in Westchester County about his citizenship status," says Alvarado.

Lawler addressed his comments a short time later during the meeting.

"Yes, I understand to hold office, you have to be a citizen," Lawler said.

Alvarado was born in Honduras. He has since lived the American dream, he tells News 12. He's the first Latino majority leader with the Westchester County Board of legislators.

He wants an apology from Lawler but not for himself.

"The community needs to hear an apology from him," says Alvarado.

Lawler says that's not going to happen.

"It's not an attack on immigrants but if you're questioned by ICE, you should cooperate," says Lawler.

Many of Alvarado's colleagues are standing by his side.

"I think it was disrespectful," says Chairman Vedat Gashi, with the Westchester County Board of Legislators.

The Democratic Caucus of the Westchester County Board of Legislators released the following statement:

"Rep. Lawler’s actions are deeply disrespectful to the Vice Chairman and an open affront to Latinos and all people of color in Westchester County and beyond. Congressman Lawler should know that all elected officials in this state, including those in Westchester County, must be U.S. citizens to hold office. We stand firmly by our colleague, José Alvarado and demand a full and immediate apology."

Top Stories

blaise haviland

Man in bulletproof vest with knife, rifle magazines arrested near Haviland Middle School

01:26
HVA Frost Freeze

Sunny and cool today in the Hudson Valley before frost develops tonight

1062026WCmeasles_2026-10-06-05-58-20

Disaster emergency issued amid rising measles outbreak across New York

01:19
melanie new ro

Man found bleeding from gunshot wound to head outside New Rochelle deli; police search for suspects

Champions Deserve Pepsi

Pepsi launches Knicks championship cans and ticket giveaway for MSG games

00:29
1062026ALLcostimes_2026-10-06-05-51-19

Spirit Halloween reveals top costume trends as spooky season gets underway

00:30
1062026WCmamguy_2026-10-06-06-08-13

Man jailed after alleged break-in spree hits 3 businesses in Mamaroneck

01:53
jackie greece

‘Call them, hug them.’ Brother mourns family killed in Greece explosion

00:25
LIGATORADERECALL106_2026-10-06-05-52-57

Over 122,000 cases of Gatorade recalled due to undeclared dyes

02:11
MT Aide Plea Deal TTT 1005_2026-10-05-21-30-56

'I felt sick.' In first interview, wife of abused Gulf War veteran breaks silence on care aide's plea deal

01:28
RTREGWCHVFirePreventionWeekDCaruso9pm

Rockland County officials warn of spike in outdoor fires spreading to homes

01:51
blaise hope alive

Behind the search: Hope Alive 845 gives missing-person cases another set of eyes

00:29
553f7390-c28b-4b25-a726-d2e8ad140f3a

Westchester high schools compete in second annual blood donation competition

00:28
RTREGWCHVMiddletownGuiltyVerdictVO4pm

Man convicted of 2019 killing of Middletown man

00:20
RTREGWCHVPoughkeepsieMurderPleaVO4pm

Poughkeepsie man admits to fatally shooting 19-year-old

00:26
RTREGWCHVRewardAnimalAbuseArrestVO4pm

Reward offered in Southeast animal abuse case

00:33
blaise cornwall

Cornwall man accused of threatening, assaulting police; 2 officers injured

00:32
Screenshot 2026-10-05 123537

12-year-old and 15-year-old arrested in burglary at popular Newburgh businesses

00:29
553f7390-c28b-4b25-a726-d2e8ad140f3a

Westchester high schools compete in second annual blood donation competition

00:16
Screenshot 2026-10-05 123552

Rollover crash leaves SUV overturned at New Rochelle intersection

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices