News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Celebrating America's 250th

Warwick baker says Hanukkah cookie post sparked death threats, hundreds of hateful comments 

A Warwick baker is speaking out against hate after she says she got death threats for posting a photo of her holiday cookies for Hanukkah. 

Blaise Gomez

Dec 20, 2023, 5:48 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

A Warwick baker says she got death threats for posting a photo of her holiday cookies for Hanukkah. 

Shannon Cheevers, who owns Shannon’s Eyes on the Pies on Pine Island Turnpike, says she posted a picture of the star-shaped cookies, dipped in chocolate with blue sprinkles, on her business Facebook page for the holiday last week with the words “Happy Hanukkah!” in the post. 

Cheevers is not Jewish but says she bakes cookies and cakes for all holidays for her customers, regardless of their religion. She says she’s posted about the Hanukkah cookies every year without incident since she opened six years ago. This year, she got several unexpected and disturbing reactions. 

“They said they were going to come and kill me and they called me a Jewish [expletive],” says Cheevers. 

The baker says she hundreds of similar hate-filled messages from people she doesn’t know. 

“I didn’t do anything wrong, and people want to come and kill me for it. It’s sad,” says Cheevers. 

IMG_4720.jpeg

One message shown to News 12 says, “I don’t need anything from you [expletive] Jews people. I’m here to say hail Hitler.” 

Cheevers says she’s concerned for her safety but won’t let the hate-filled messages keep her from celebrating all holidays and religions through her confections. 

“Happy Hanukkah, merry Christmas, happy Kwanza. Happy whatever. Just happy is all I want,” Cheevers says. 

More cookies for other holidays are also available for sale in the store. 

Cheevers says she reported the comments and threats to police.  

More Stories

Top Stories

00:46
police investigation police lights mon copy

Westchester woman found dead in Ireland; police investigating murder

02:08
HVF P1 AM 1

Warmer temps with storm chances to finish the week for the Hudson Valley

02:10
Screenshot 2026-07-09 052227

Son charged with murder in death of 71-year-old Scarsdale mother

00:37
7092026WHITEPLAINSBABYINCAR_2026-07-09-06-11-19

Police bodycam shows rescue of 3-month-old locked inside car in White Plains

00:20
Rock into vehicle

Rock crashes through windshield on Taconic State Parkway, driver narrowly escapes serious injury

03:35
Cox

Records reveal prior charges against Montrose VA aide accused of abusing veteran

00:24
792026WCfbi_2026-07-09-05-12-37

Westchester man accused of impersonating FBI agent at Rye Playland

01:46
792026WCrt_2026-07-09-05-28-57

Road Trip Close to Home: Red Rooster Drive-In serves up nostalgia, burgers and family fun in Brewster

02:01
0708orangetowndatabankcenter_2026-07-08-21-11-59

Crowds pack Orangetown Town Hall as controversial data center expansion faces Planning Board review

00:59
Breeze Security Breach

Passenger removed from Breeze flight after disturbance on trip from Westchester to Florida

01:35
WC 430PM WED_Statue Vandalism_ajc_2026-07-08-16-53-53

Sybill Ludington statue vandalized days after political rhetoric found on Declaration display

00:44
0708strongarmofthelaw_2026-07-08-19-40-37

New book dedicated to Westchester native who spent decades protecting region's waterways

01:40
WC 430PM WED_PFAs Dutchess_ajc_2026-07-08-17-02-46

Wappinger gets help to update water plant that is too expensive to run at full capacity

02:04
Image

7-year-old girl killed after being struck by school bus in Monsey

00:21
DSC01116 copy

Connecticut man charged after 22 ghost guns, assault-style rifles and cocaine seized in Westchester sting

02:17
Screenshot 2026-07-08 052435

Trees continue falling across the Hudson Valley days after storms move out

Screenshot 2026-07-08 063348

Fully engulfed garage collapses as firefighters battle Peekskill blaze

01:47
Tomato

Trouble with your tomatoes? Try these 5 tips to keep getting tasty fruit all summer long

01:48
78whatscooking_2026-07-08-06-06-45

What’s Cooking: Grilled swordfish with mango salsa

01:56
Screenshot 2026-07-07 122844

Mahopac church left with significant damage in wake of recent storms

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices