State police ‘not sure’ about leaked documents in Edward Holley case

According to the newly released media reports, USA Today obtained leaked state police documents that allege District Attorney Dave Hoovler “undermined and interfered” with the decades-old murder probe.

Blaise Gomez

Feb 5, 2024, 8:52 PM

Updated 169 days ago

Share:

There's been another twist in the Megan McDonald case: reports of leaked police documents have surfaced that seemingly points fingers at the Orange County district attorney and a county court judge.
According to the newly released media reports, USA Today obtained leaked state police documents that allege District Attorney Dave Hoovler “undermined and interfered” with the decades-old murder probe by allegedly not disclosing information revealed to him by a second person of interest in 2008, who was his client at the time, before he was elected to office.
“Any suggestion that I did anything to interfere with the investigation into Megan McDonald’s death is as categorically false as it is offensive,” says Hoovler. “I cannot speculate as to the motivations of those involved in the recent reporting regarding the investigation. Ethical rules prevent me from making any further comments about a former client."
The media reports also allege Orange County Court Judge Craig Brown once questioned if his own relative was a suspect and claim he denied two search warrants during the probe.
News 12 was unable to immediately reach Brown for comment.
Holley, who is McDonald’s ex-boyfriend, is accused of bludgeoning the 20-year-old woman more than a dozen times and leaving her body near a dumpster in a Town of Wallkill field in 2003. He was arrested by state police last April for second-degree murder after authorities said new DNA evidence linked him to the murder.
The case has been riddled with problems since.
Hoovler was noticeably absent from the state police press conference announcing the arrest and stepped down from prosecuting the case, claiming that his office was never notified charges would be filed and citing a conflict of interest with his former client, who died in 2010.
Special prosecutor Julia Cornachio was assigned to the case and given the daunting task of reviewing 20 years of evidence. Holley was let go from custody after an indictment couldn’t immediately be handed down, as required by law.
The Wawayanda man was indicted last week after the complicated case was presented to a Grand Jury and ordered to Orange County Jail by Judge Hyun Chin Kim on $500,000 bail.
“For the first time in 21 years, Edward Holley is going to jail for the murder of Megan McDonald. Our family is beyond grateful, and we are relieved,” said Karen Whalen, the victim’s sister, after Holley’s arraignment.
Holley denies killing McDonald and said following his arrest last April, “I’m definitely not guilty. I loved Meagan with all my heart."
His defense attorney, Paul Weber, maintains authorities have the wrong person.
“That’s why Mr. Hoovler never put the case into the grand jury because he knows they’re on a wild goose chase,” said Weber in an interview with News 12 last November.
Cornachio declined to comment on the allegations during the pending case.
The McDonald family issued this statement to News 12 through their attorney, John Beatty, saying, "Enough with the fake outrage. Stop abusing victims and their families. You, David Hoovler, will be held accountable."
News 12 has not been able to obtain a copy of the leaked document. State Police Troop F spokesperson Steve Nevell says they’re “not sure where the reporter received his information,” and declined to comment further.


More from News 12
1:48
A look back at President Biden, VP Harris' visits to the Hudson Valley

A look back at President Biden, VP Harris' visits to the Hudson Valley

1:38
Gloomy skies, showers and storms through Thursday in the Hudson Valley

Gloomy skies, showers and storms through Thursday in the Hudson Valley

1:47
'I don't know what the answer is.' Newburgh residents may have to live with dangerous intersection indefinitely

'I don't know what the answer is.' Newburgh residents may have to live with dangerous intersection indefinitely

1:29
Oklahoma woman sentenced to 4-12 years for fatal drunk-driving crash in Newburgh

Oklahoma woman sentenced to 4-12 years for fatal drunk-driving crash in Newburgh

1:42
Special election in Yorktown today will fill vacant Town Council seat

Special election in Yorktown today will fill vacant Town Council seat

0:48
Made in the Hudson Valley: 'Mister Croissant' bakery brings world-class pastries to Middletown

Made in the Hudson Valley: 'Mister Croissant' bakery brings world-class pastries to Middletown

0:43
Secret Service director steps down after assassination attempt against ex-President Trump at rally

Secret Service director steps down after assassination attempt against ex-President Trump at rally

0:21
$17 million awarded to repair Callicoon Bridge in Sullivan County

$17 million awarded to repair Callicoon Bridge in Sullivan County

0:28
Orange County man fatally struck in hit-and-run crash in the Bronx; man charged

Orange County man fatally struck in hit-and-run crash in the Bronx; man charged

0:27
New York, New Jersey & Delaware sued for failing to protect endangered Atlantic sturgeon

New York, New Jersey & Delaware sued for failing to protect endangered Atlantic sturgeon

1:02
Headlines: New Rochelle stabbing, home burglary, New Rochelle man pleads guilty in Bronx shooting

Headlines: New Rochelle stabbing, home burglary, New Rochelle man pleads guilty in Bronx shooting

0:54
Jayne Street Bridge in Orange County gets $1.35M boost for restoration

Jayne Street Bridge in Orange County gets $1.35M boost for restoration

2:27
Made in the Hudson Valley: Hudson Beach Glass gives visitors the chance to become glassblowers themselves

Made in the Hudson Valley: Hudson Beach Glass gives visitors the chance to become glassblowers themselves

0:21
Eastchester police mourn loss of former officer Alex Bonci

Eastchester police mourn loss of former officer Alex Bonci

2:09
Hudson Valley congressman backs Vice President Kamala Harris for new presidential nominee

Hudson Valley congressman backs Vice President Kamala Harris for new presidential nominee

1:37
Food hall of the future comes to Larchmont

Food hall of the future comes to Larchmont

AP survey: Harris has enough delegate support to become the Democratic Party nominee

AP survey: Harris has enough delegate support to become the Democratic Party nominee

1:34
Lewisboro residents address concerns about green-energy provider program

Lewisboro residents address concerns about green-energy provider program