Spring Valley firefighters express outrage over plea deal offered in 2021 fatal Evergreen fire case

News 12 learned Wednesday from several sources that DA Walsh allegedly made a deal with the father-and-son rabbis accused of starting the fire.

Lee Danuff and Ben Nandy

Jun 15, 2023, 9:14 PM

Updated 313 days ago

Share:

Firefighters in Spring Valley say they are outraged after learning about a plea deal in the 2021 fatal Evergreen fire case. 
Some, including Spring Valley firefighter Justin Schwartz, are calling on Rockland District Attorney Tom Walsh to step down. 
Walsh originally charged six people in connection to the March 2021 fire at the Evergreen Assisted Living Facility that killed firefighter Jared Lloyd and a 79-year-old resident.
MORE: Playing With Fire Nathaniel Sommer and his son Aaron Sommer were charged with manslaughter. Charges against two village building inspectors were eventually dropped, and the two Evergreen employees pleaded guilty and will not have to serve any time in jail.
News 12 learned Wednesday from several sources that Walsh allegedly made a deal with the father-and-son rabbis accused of starting the fire. News 12 was told the deal will allow both to avoid prison time if the judge signs off on the deal. 
"We go in day in and day out to fight fires, and then we don't come home. Nobody gives a damn," says Schwartz. 
Investigators said the Sommers started the Evergreen fire while using a blowtorch to kosherize the kitchen.
Three months after the fire, Walsh stood with Lloyd's family at a news conference, promising accountability for those involved.
"We owe them justice and again, we offer our condolences," said Walsh.  News 12 spoke with Lloyd's father Wednesday,  who said he was devastated by the development.
"We waited two years with many different delays ... and tonight we get word that the father and son are going to be given probation. That's not the outcome we were looking for," says Calvin Lloyd. 
News 12 was told that the plea deal is going to be finalized on Tuesday in Rockland County Court. It is ultimately up to the judge to approve the terms of the deal. The Lloyd family has filed a wrongful-death civil lawsuit, which is still in play. They're seeking money damages from the village, the Evergreen's owner, Nathaniel Sommer and Aaron Sommer.
Note: An earlier version of this story incorrectly identified Justin Schwartz as a fire captain. Schwartz is a firefighter.


More from News 12
1:55
Westchester residents join Putnam neighbors to oppose proposed Carmel battery plant

Westchester residents join Putnam neighbors to oppose proposed Carmel battery plant

2:15
Pop-up showers with breaks of sun today, mostly sunny for the rest of the workweek

Pop-up showers with breaks of sun today, mostly sunny for the rest of the workweek

1:02
Composting can save money, help gardens and save the planet. Here are 10 tips to get you started

Composting can save money, help gardens and save the planet. Here are 10 tips to get you started

2:01
Orange County hosts crime victims' vigil

Orange County hosts crime victims' vigil

0:37
Authorities: Man severely burned outside sports complex in Warwick

Authorities: Man severely burned outside sports complex in Warwick

0:29
Netflix to film parts of conspiracy thriller 'Zero Day' in Nyack on Wednesday

Netflix to film parts of conspiracy thriller 'Zero Day' in Nyack on Wednesday

1:45
A closer look at 4 laws in approved NY state budget designed to combat retail theft

A closer look at 4 laws in approved NY state budget designed to combat retail theft

2:41
Kindness never goes out of style: Social media request helps provide prom dresses for kids with special needs

Kindness never goes out of style: Social media request helps provide prom dresses for kids with special needs

State police: Victim of I-684 car crash identified as convicted murderer in country illegally

State police: Victim of I-684 car crash identified as convicted murderer in country illegally

0:56
Brooklyn man charged with scamming Westchester resident out of $28K

Brooklyn man charged with scamming Westchester resident out of $28K

2:00
Another fire at Spring Valley apartment complex; county officials issue one violation

Another fire at Spring Valley apartment complex; county officials issue one violation

0:39
Source: 16-year-old arrested in Newburgh stabbing near high school

Source: 16-year-old arrested in Newburgh stabbing near high school

Montgomery man charged, officer’s conduct under review following Walmart larceny

Montgomery man charged, officer’s conduct under review following Walmart larceny

0:50
Police: Goshen home vandalized in hate crime

Police: Goshen home vandalized in hate crime

0:18
Fire outside L.L. Bean Store in Town of Ulster quickly extinguished

Fire outside L.L. Bean Store in Town of Ulster quickly extinguished

0:27
Police: Wallkill man reported missing found dead in home

Police: Wallkill man reported missing found dead in home

0:36
Wake and funeral announced for Westchester correction officer killed in crash

Wake and funeral announced for Westchester correction officer killed in crash

0:20
3 Hudson Valley small towns ranked among best places for retirement

3 Hudson Valley small towns ranked among best places for retirement

Vote 2024: Ask your questions for Congressional District 16 Democratic candidates

Vote 2024: Ask your questions for Congressional District 16 Democratic candidates

0:32
Naming contest announced for baby falcons on Mario M. Cuomo Bridge

Naming contest announced for baby falcons on Mario M. Cuomo Bridge