News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys
Clear
53°
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys

Second Middletown football coach resigns amid eligibility fallout

Assistant coach Isaac Cayetano stepped down following the departure of head coach Tim Strenfel, who resigned after nearly a decade in the role.

Cole McDonnell

•

Nov 19, 2026, 4:49 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

An assistant football coach from Middletown High School resigned in the wake of the team's football controversy.

Assistant coach Isaac Cayetano stepped down following the departure of head coach Tim Strenfel, who resigned after nearly a decade in the role.

In an exclusive interview with News 12 on Wednesday, Cayetano acknowledged that the coaching staff bears responsibility but questioned why athletic department officials failed to catch the problem before it cost the team its season. According to Cayetano, Strenfel sought and received approval from athletic director Justin Sturge before adding a player from the school’s soccer team as a kicker during the regular season.

Middletown's undefeated season came to an abrupt end last week after an eligibility error forced the team to forfeit.

Superintendent Amy Creeden says the district's investigation into what went wrong is still ongoing.

Top Stories

00:22
Screenshot 19-11-2026 131710 vod.prod.alticeustech.com

17-year-old Newburgh Free Academy student killed in Vails Gate house fire

01:40
HV STORMWATCH

STORM WATCH: Coastal storm could bring wind and rain, disrupting travel starting Sunday

01:29
RGNAIRPLANERESCUE1119430P_2026-11-19-16-42-19

Respiratory therapist hailed as hero after helping revive passenger midflight

SEXUAL ABUSE ARREST MONITOR copy

DA: Mount Vernon man indicted for allegedly raping and sexually abusing a girl under 17

00:35
Screenshot 2026-11-19 164802

Second Middletown football coach resigns amid eligibility fallout

00:25
1119jpmorganchase_2026-11-19-16-45-59

JPMorgan Chase third-party services target of cyberattack

01:04
blaiseduckfarmfirepkg1119_2026-11-19-16-48-55_16-33-35,19

Massive fire kills ducks and geese, destroys buildings at one of nation’s only two major foie gras producers

00:30
wildchaseplea1119_2026-11-19-16-54-13

NYC man pleads guilty after Saw Mill River Parkway police chase

01:01
Screenshot 2026-11-18 211310

Custodian charged after allegedly 'striking' student at Hempstead Elementary School

10:52
flatbush

NYC councilmember gives update on recovery efforts in Flatbush building collapse

01:54
blaise mdtn

Middletown head football coach resigns following playoff disqualification

01:59
1119katdrunkdriver_2026-11-19-06-22-47

Bronx man arrested for aggravated DWI after wrong-way crash on Thruway in Harrison

01:45
Screenshot 2026-11-17 131619

Road Trip: The Village Confectionary is a sweet tradition in the heart of Sleepy Hollow

01:53
WCTGivingTravel11184p_2026-11-18-16-41-02

How to prepare for Thanksgiving travel in the tri-state

01:29
Screenshot 2026-11-18 at 9.56.32 PM

White Plains first responders take part in specialized heavy rescue training

00:23
Screenshot 2026-11-18 at 9.55.35 PM

Rockland man sentenced for sexually abusing 8-year-old

07:20
Screenshot 2026-11-18 213038

Historic cosmic milestone reached: NASA's Voyager 1 Spacecraft is now the farthest human-made object in history

00:56
blaise chester

Chester comptroller on paid leave calls allegations against him ‘political,’ says supervisor approved work for another town

00:33
LIgtalaunchkk_2026-11-18-17-39-36

Pausing work? 1.5 million expected to take day off for GTA 6 release

01:39
1118trainstrikenoon_2026-11-18-12-05-10

Driver killed after NJ Transit train strikes vehicle in Nanuet

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices