News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys
Clear
40°
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys

Middletown head football coach resigns following playoff disqualification

The resignation comes as the school district launches an investigation into the eligibility mistake that ended the team's historic undefeated season.

Blaise Gomez

•

Nov 19, 2026, 6:01 AM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

The fallout continues at Middletown High School, where an undefeated football team’s championship dreams were shattered by an eligibility violation — and now the players have lost their head coach.

Head coach Tim Strenfel resigned Tuesday after nearly a decade leading the program, as the Middletown City School District continues investigating the mistake that forced the team to forfeit its postseason victory.

In an exclusive interview with News 12, assistant football coach Isaac Cayetano acknowledged that the coaching staff bears responsibility but questioned why athletic department officials failed to catch the problem before it cost the team its season. According to Cayetano, Strenfel sought and received approval from athletic director Justin Sturge before adding a player from the school’s soccer team as a kicker during the regular season.

The player was eligible to participate in regular-season games but had not played the three games required to qualify for postseason competition. Cayetano says that requirement was never properly communicated to Strenfel, who was apparently unaware of the rule despite his nearly decade-long tenure as head coach.

Court documents also indicate that Sturge attended a training session approximately a month earlier that addressed the postseason eligibility requirement.

The kicker went on to play 53 seconds in a postseason victory without scoring any points. Nevertheless, his participation violated eligibility rules, resulting in the forfeiture of Middletown’s playoff win and ending the team’s hopes of competing for a Section IX championship.

Cayetano says Strenfel should have known the rule but believes the athletic director and David Coates, who serves as a district consultant involved with Section IX athletics, should have flagged the issue.

“You can blame him. You can blame me. You can blame everyone on the staff. However, we have bosses as well, and we have people who are supposed to educate us,” Cayetano said.

He also raised questions about the team’s postseason roster, saying the kicker was not listed on it — another missed opportunity, in his view, to identify the eligibility problem. Cayetano says the athletic director is responsible for that roster, although the district has not confirmed that responsibility.

Section IX Executive Director Greg Ransom told News 12 that student-athlete eligibility is solely the responsibility of school districts, not Section IX or NYSPHSAA. He said Coates has no responsibility for eligibility compliance on behalf of Section IX and that it is up to Middletown to determine who should be held accountable.

Middletown had completed its first undefeated regular season in 65 years before the eligibility controversy brought its postseason run to an abrupt end. Valley Central ultimately took Middletown’s place in the Section IX championship game Saturday, defeating Newburgh 16-6.

IMG_8928.jpeg

Middletown challenged the disqualification through the athletic appeals process before taking the matter to Orange County Supreme Court on Nov. 13. Following a nearly two-hour hearing, the district withdrew its petition after the judge indicated she would not grant the requested relief.

Superintendent Amy Creeden told News 12 the district’s investigation into the circumstances surrounding the eligibility violation is ongoing and will be extensive. The district has not announced whether any additional athletic department personnel will face disciplinary action.

Editors note: Assistant football coach Isaac Cayetano resigned following his exclusive interview with News 12 and Wednesday’s report.

IMG_8956.jpeg

More From News12

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices