News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files

Rockland NAACP leaders join calls for justice in aftermath of fatal Evergreen fire plea deal

The leaders wrote letters saying that they are outraged that the father and son who started the fire will not get jail time.

News 12 Staff

Aug 10, 2023, 10:38 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Three Rockland NAACP leaders are demanding justice after father-and-son rabbis received a plea deal in the fatal 2021 Evergreen fire case.

The NAACP leaders sent letters both to the Rockland County District Attorney Tom Walsh and a county court judge.

Rockland County legislator urges DA to answer questions about controversial plea deal amid calls for his resignation

Who is the judge presiding over the fatal Evergreen Court fire case?

They wrote that they are outraged by the plea deal with no jail time for Rabbis Aaron and Nathaniel Sommer. The father and son started the deadly 2021 fire at Evergreen home for adults when they used a blow torch to Kosherize the facility for Passover.

The fire killed resident Oliver Hueston and volunteer firefighter Jared Lloyd.

Back in June, several Rockland firefighters expressed anger over the plea deal. Now, the NAACP joined in, adding that the decision indicates the lack of value some people place on Black lives since firefighter Jared Lloyd was Black and the NAACP encourages people of color to be volunteer first responders.

Spring Valley FD: Plea deal in fatal Evergreen fire is ‘slap in the face’ to firefighters

Rockland fire departments call for DA to step down over plea deal in 2021 fatal fire

"The best honor would be justice and that man did not come home to his child. So we felt that was a slap in the face to the first responders' community as well as the African American community and we couldn't go silent just letting that happen," said Wilbur T. Aldridge, regional director of the Mid-Hudson Westchester NAACP.

Aldridge said Walsh and the judge had not responded to the letter as of Thursday night.

A spokesperson for the Walsh's office told News 12, "...The agreement by the people is to the plea being entered into, the manslaughter counts and the reckless endangerment counts. As far as the sentencing, that's in the discretion of the court."

More Stories

Top Stories

01:50
Screenshot 2026-04-10 224403

Teens stopped before attempting dangerous subway surfing stunt in the Bronx

01:32
BX F P2 PM 2

Summer sizzle arrives next week in The Bronx

02:10
fentanylpackagingmillsbustCM_2026-04-10-17-13-32

K-9 exposed during major fentanyl raid in the Bronx and Washington Heights

00:48
bronxdoccentervosot10pZC_2026-04-10-22-23-19

Legendary graffiti photos now on display at the Bronx Documentary Center

00:27
291cacdf-355b-4038-bb3d-aa4f20406b9d

15 people hurt, one seriously, in crash involving MTA bus in Edenwald

01:41
pelhampkwysrorallyCM_2026-04-10-17-26-39

Pelham Parkway residents rally at City Hall against proposed supportive housing

02:43
AP26101005788713

Artemis II astronauts return from moon with a splashdown to close out a record-breaking lunar voyage

ADAMS ALBANIA TWO

Former NYC Mayor Eric Adams granted Albanian citizenship

02:20
BXMAMDANI100THDAY04105P_2026-04-10-17-21-46

Mamdani’s 100th Day: What the NYC mayor has achieved, and what’s still ahead

01:51
BXEMSASSAULT04105P_2026-04-10-17-16-01

‘He's not a monster,’ says distraught girlfriend of man accused of assaulting EMS workers

HER

Brooklyn man arrested for stalking R&B singer H.E.R., sent messages saying 'I miss you'

01:28
49rebuildingthebronx_2026-04-09-06-23-00

Bronx attorney urges families to consider trusts to manage assets

00:28
bostonrdmotoryclecrash12pZC_2026-04-10-14-05-54

Motorcyclist critically injured in Williamsbridge hit-and-run

00:29
410vitaminrecall_2026-04-10-09-07-51

More than 350,000 iron-containing supplements recalled for lacking child‑resistant packaging

02:22
animalabuseconcernsCM_2026-04-08-17-08-53

Exclusive: Disturbing video of dog attacking opossum in Baychester sparks animal cruelty investigation

00:29
bronxwoodaveshootingarrest5pZC_2026-04-09-17-31-22

Arrest made in killing of Williamsbridge man shot in the head steps from his home

02:00
mopedvbusfolo5pZC_2026-04-09-18-27-21

Video shows Bronx moped driver flee from police before fatal crash with MTA bus

03:41
erikduransentencingCM_2026-04-09-17-10-34

Former NYPD sergeant sentenced to 3 to 9 years for killing Bronx man with cooler

00:23
BXBx3BusDriverPunchedArrest410265A_2026-04-10-05-38-32

Bronx man accused of punching an MTA bus operator

00:24
LIRICERECALL410_2026-04-10-05-20-58

Jasmine rice sold at Wegmans, other stores recalled for possible 'foreign material'

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices