Release of suspect charged in domestic violence case renews calls for review of bail reform

A disturbing domestic violence arrest and subsequent release in Orange County has led to renewed calls for a second look at bail reform.

News 12 Staff

Feb 18, 2021, 11:27 PM

Updated 1,248 days ago

Share:

A disturbing domestic violence arrest and subsequent release in Orange County has led to renewed calls for a second look at bail reform.
A Dutchess County mother says a two-hourlong domestic violence attack left her blind in her right eye.
"He had his arms and was right on top of me and looked right into my eyes and said this would be a perfect murder-suicide," she says.
The Orange County Sheriff's Office says 44-year-old John Pahucki, from Wawayanda, was charged with second-degree assault and harassment in the January attack.
Both felonies are eligible for bail, but prosecutors say Pahucki was released without it.
It's a frightening reality for the victim and Pahucki's ex-wife, Vanessa Petrossian, who says he has a history of domestic violence.
"How disturbed are you that he would be released without bail even though the offenses are bail eligible?," asks Petrossian. "To hear her recount the stories, it's torture. It wasn't just a slap in the face, it was hours of beatings that she and I both received."
Sen. Mike Martucci says this case and others like it are reason to repeal bail reform adding, "New York's dangerous bail elimination law continues to fuel a cycle of crime, and as evidenced here, has caused a disturbing rise in intimate partner violence. This failed catch-and-release policy is putting victims at immediate risk of more abuse. Sadly, there are countless cases just like this one."
In this case, both women have orders of protection in place, but Petrossian says the order of protection is just a piece of paper.
News 12 reached John Pahucki by phone and asked him about the allegations, but he declined to comment.


More from News 12
0:27
Freedom Fest event honors veterans in Orange County

Freedom Fest event honors veterans in Orange County

2:01
Sun, clouds and a possible stray shower in the Hudson Valley

Sun, clouds and a possible stray shower in the Hudson Valley

0:34
Over 1,600 U.S. flights cancelled Saturday due to global technology outage

Over 1,600 U.S. flights cancelled Saturday due to global technology outage

1:31
Officials: Calls to 988 have increased since its creation 2 years ago

Officials: Calls to 988 have increased since its creation 2 years ago

2:02
Family, friends memorialize former Westchester County legislator Herman Keith

Family, friends memorialize former Westchester County legislator Herman Keith

1:51
Community barbecue in White Plains spreads positivity, honors late residents

Community barbecue in White Plains spreads positivity, honors late residents

1:14
Yonkers recognizes National Park and Recreation Month

Yonkers recognizes National Park and Recreation Month

1:51
Police: Toddler hit by car in Rockland County, left critically injured

Police: Toddler hit by car in Rockland County, left critically injured

0:27
Police: Yonkers man tried to sell narcotic stronger than fentanyl to undercover officer

Police: Yonkers man tried to sell narcotic stronger than fentanyl to undercover officer

1:41
 Officials: COVID-19 has hit high levels in several states, including Connecticut

Officials: COVID-19 has hit high levels in several states, including Connecticut

0:26
ATVs banned from public property in Yorktown

ATVs banned from public property in Yorktown

1:41
 Officials: COVID-19 has hit high levels in several states, including Connecticut

Officials: COVID-19 has hit high levels in several states, including Connecticut

0:22
Yonkers FD to experiment with thermal imaging cameras

Yonkers FD to experiment with thermal imaging cameras

1:59
Global computer outage impacts vital Hudson Valley services

Global computer outage impacts vital Hudson Valley services

0:38
Authorities: Ossining man threatened to kill US Postal workers, burn down post offices

Authorities: Ossining man threatened to kill US Postal workers, burn down post offices

0:45
Police: Poughkeepsie woman seriously injured in crash on South Road

Police: Poughkeepsie woman seriously injured in crash on South Road

0:50
Ronald McDonald House in Valhalla hosts 2nd annual 'Christmas in July' charity event

Ronald McDonald House in Valhalla hosts 2nd annual 'Christmas in July' charity event

2:01
Doctors urge parents to get their children in for doctor visit ahead of new school year

Doctors urge parents to get their children in for doctor visit ahead of new school year

1:52
Tech outage: They didn't miss their flight, their flight missed them

Tech outage: They didn't miss their flight, their flight missed them

1:56
Aunt, former caseworker push for probe into Sullivan County CPS after foster child’s hot car death

Aunt, former caseworker push for probe into Sullivan County CPS after foster child’s hot car death