Police: DNA advancements could help solve Mamaroneck cold case

Nearly 13 years ago, a beachgoer made a grisly discovery in a suitcase that had washed ashore.

News 12 Staff

Feb 7, 2020, 10:54 PM

Updated 1,561 days ago

Share:

A cold case has led village of Mamaroneck Police Detective Sgt. Mark Gatta back to the beach at Harbor Island Park.
Nearly 13 years ago, a beachgoer made a grisly discovery in a suitcase that had washed ashore.
"Child poking around it with a stick, opened it up and observed what was part of a female," says Gatta.
Investigators say the decomposed torso was likely that of Hispanic or light-skinned black woman between 35 to 50 years old.
A tattoo of two cherries on a stem was found on the body. That led investigators to name the murder mystery the "Cherries Doe" case.
Police thought the tattoo would be their best lead to identify the woman, but nothing panned out.
Now police are hoping advancements in DNA technology will help them identify the victim, should a family member come forward.
"If they gave their DNA, we can check that against Cherries', and see that it is indeed the relation, and if we can do that, then we have a chance in identifying her," says Gatta
Nearly three weeks after the woman's torso washed up in a suitcase at the beach, another gruesome discovery was made in the case -- this time on Long Island. A dismembered woman's foot washed ashore in Cold Spring Harbor.
A couple days later, another foot washed up on Oyster Bay Beach on property owned by former Cablevision President Charles Dolan.
Mamaroneck police say the feet that washed ashore on Long Island indeed belonged to Cherries Doe.


More from News 12
0:25
Goshen man pleads guilty to predatory sexual assault of child

Goshen man pleads guilty to predatory sexual assault of child

1:47
Mostly cloudy skies, cool temperatures and chance of stray shower in the Hudson Valley

Mostly cloudy skies, cool temperatures and chance of stray shower in the Hudson Valley

1:53
Hudson Valley unites to help Ukraine, continues local efforts to help war-torn country

Hudson Valley unites to help Ukraine, continues local efforts to help war-torn country

0:20
Police: Spikes deployed by officers to stop car during pursuit in Town of Bedford

Police: Spikes deployed by officers to stop car during pursuit in Town of Bedford

0:30
Yorktown Grange Fair to celebrate its 100th anniversary this September

Yorktown Grange Fair to celebrate its 100th anniversary this September

1:48
City of Mount Vernon celebrates and reflects 70 years since landmark Brown v. Board of Ed decision

City of Mount Vernon celebrates and reflects 70 years since landmark Brown v. Board of Ed decision

0:27
Man arrested for hate crime at Kingston synagogue

Man arrested for hate crime at Kingston synagogue

0:31
Westchester County DA: Peekskill man pleads guilty to gunning down man in front of his children

Westchester County DA: Peekskill man pleads guilty to gunning down man in front of his children

0:47
Two Middletown state troopers honored for heroism

Two Middletown state troopers honored for heroism

1:44
Caught on camera: Person seen taking down Israeli flag from Rockland County business

Caught on camera: Person seen taking down Israeli flag from Rockland County business

0:59
Man who allegedly set Warwick home of trooper’s family on fire indicted for attempted murder

Man who allegedly set Warwick home of trooper’s family on fire indicted for attempted murder

1:31
DEC tranquilizes, safely relocates bear in Poughkeepsie neighborhood

DEC tranquilizes, safely relocates bear in Poughkeepsie neighborhood

1:45
Transfiguration School set to close with little notice, leaving parents scrambling to find new schools

Transfiguration School set to close with little notice, leaving parents scrambling to find new schools

0:50
New firefighter training center opens in Pomona

New firefighter training center opens in Pomona

0:53
29th annual Today's Students Tomorrow's Teachers brunch celebrates future educators

29th annual Today's Students Tomorrow's Teachers brunch celebrates future educators

0:19
Playland Park's Gondola Wheel closed due to active Osprey nesting

Playland Park's Gondola Wheel closed due to active Osprey nesting

0:35
Ossining family awarded over $23 million for medical malpractice lawsuit against Westchester Medical Center

Ossining family awarded over $23 million for medical malpractice lawsuit against Westchester Medical Center

1:04
Royal Regency Hotel in Yonkers celebrates 30 years of business

Royal Regency Hotel in Yonkers celebrates 30 years of business

0:41
Lakeland Central School District joins search for 2 missing Westchester teens

Lakeland Central School District joins search for 2 missing Westchester teens

0:23
New York Rangers beat Carolina Hurricanes 5-3 to advance to Eastern Conference Final

New York Rangers beat Carolina Hurricanes 5-3 to advance to Eastern Conference Final