News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys
Sunny
56°
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys

North Castle neighborhood dealing with rat infestation demands someone address issue

One homeowner said she has spent more than $1,000 in three weeks dealing with the sudden rodent infestation.

Jonathan Gordon

•

Aug 14, 2024, 5:46 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

At first glance, Palmer Avenue in the North White Plains section of the town of North Castle seems as pristine as any suburban neighborhood, but a closer look might turn your stomach.

"I saw something run along the wall and said 'That's a little too big for a field mouse,' and sure enough it was a rat," homeowner Holly Mottola said.

Holly Mottola has owned her North White Plains home for nearly three decades without any issues, but everything changed three weeks ago. That's when she said she noticed the first rodent on her property. Three weeks later, she spent nearly $1,000 trapping and killing almost 100 rats in her backyard.

"I'm beside myself," she said. "I could even cry just now. It's just too much already."

Mottola said her home isn't the only one affected. Several others around the neighborhood are dealing with the sudden infestation.

She said the issue has turned her property unsafe and unusable for her family and dogs.

"If you walk around back this was a beautiful yard," Mottola said. "We can't use it."

Videos she shared with News 12 show many rats on the North Broadway Gulf gas station that runs along her property line. News 12 stopped by the gas station and saw half a dozen dead rats and mice in the parking lot with several traps put out to kill even more.

The owner, Asif, didn't deny the issue but said it wasn't unique to his property. He blamed the Casa Mary restaurant that borders his business.

He showed News 12 tunnels that he claims are where the rodents come from. Asif also pointed out garbage bags left out and open dumpsters on the restaurant's property.

"This business has been here for the last 22 years, never had an issue, Asif said. "These people just opened up a few months ago and since then we've been noticing rats coming over here."

The restaurant opened next door only a few months ago and denied any responsibility. News 12 went through the restaurant and staff showed it was clean and even produced records detailing routine exterminator visits.

"I don't think there is what you're saying like a lot of mice over there," a man who identified himself as a manager-level employee said. "I don't see even one."

A spokesperson for Westchester County told News 12 that the Health Department has received complaints about both properties and is working to address the issue.

Hours after News 12 stopped by the restaurant, so did a pair of health inspectors for a surprise inspection. News 12 does not know the results of the visit at this time.

As for Mottola and her neighbors, it's not so much about who is responsible, just that something is done. She said the whole neighborhood deserves to have their peace of mind and properties back.

"It's destroyed my outside living that I usually have with my family," Mottola said. "It's destroyed it."

Top Stories

02:06
Screenshot 2026-11-16 115121

Horace Greeley mourns student killed in crash as 3 classmates remain critically injured

01:25
hv2

Days and days of sun, pleasant temperatures in the Hudson Valley

IMG 8819

Firefighters battle massive blaze at New Paltz wine supply business

Bank Jugging MS 1202_2025-12-02-17-06-46

Customers at some of the nation's largest banks are reporting difficulty accessing accounts online

IMG 8788

17-year-old killed in Vails Gate house fire; four firefighters injured

02:03
Regeneron

'Just getting started.' Inside Regeneron's multibillion-dollar push for the next generation of medicine

Screenshot 2026-11-16 054448

LIVE UPDATES: Flight delays and cancellations remain as tri-state airports work to recover from ground stop

01:23
thanksgiving1

You can grow your favorite Thanksgiving veggies in November, here's how

00:25
police chase generic

Stolen Jeep chase ends with spike strip and 3 arrests in Putnam County

02:06
Screenshot 2026-11-12 120037

Made in the Hudson Valley: Family-run Plastic-Craft Products carries on more than 90 years of manufacturing

01:48
turkey1

The Cost Of: Thanksgiving turkey, ham and drinks

00:24
water main break generic

Fifth water main break hits Westchester this month as Greenburgh crews make repairs

00:23
Missing Yonkers Man

Statewide missing vulnerable adult alert issued for Westchester man

00:40
RTREGCTWCHVICEArrest11152026VO9pm_2026-11-15-21-35-45

Man arrested in crash that killed University of New Haven student from Stony Point

00:59
RTREGWCHVAbandonHotelFireDCaruso6pm_2026-11-15-18-18-24

Purchase fire under investigation after blaze engulfs vacant building

01:23
li12pmbolhicksvilleshooting_2026-11-15-12-12-33

Yonkers man charged after accidentally shooting and killing his brother in Hicksville, prosecutors say

00:27
1114whiteplainsstabbing_2026-11-14-07-23-19

Suspect caught after stabbing near popular White Plains shopping mall

00:30
image

Mount Vernon man indicted for attempted murder in stabbing of sanitation worker

TURKEYPIC

Stop & Shop launches Thanksgiving meal deal with turkey, sides and pie for under $40

01:35
RGNARMONKCRASH11156P_2026-11-15-18-21-30

1 teen killed, 3 others critically injured in Armonk single-car crash

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices