News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Clear
58°
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics

Montgomery mayor accused by residents of vandalizing safe, passing frivolous laws

Rita Santo says the safe had roughly $200 in cash inside and belonged to her group, which oversaw the Montgomery Senior Center for decades - until Hembury took office.

Blaise Gomez

Sep 30, 2024, 8:15 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Political tensions are running high in the Village of Montgomery where the new mayor is being accused by some residents of creating frivolous laws, keeping people from meetings and breaking into a safe.

The latter incident was partially caught on video in September when Mayor Mike Hembury, who took office in April, is seemingly seen hovering over an open safe that allegedly had the door removed.

“It was taken apart and the mayor was bopping numbers,” says Montgomery Advisory Board President Rita Santo. “Not only was it open, but the door was on top of it. The underside of the door was laying on top of it. I ran over and said, 'Where’s the money in the safe?'”

Rita Santo says the safe had roughly $200 in cash inside and belonged to her group, which oversaw the Montgomery Senior Center for decades - until Hembury took office.

Santo says the Advisory Board was “evicted” from the center Sept. 3 without any notice, and that Hembury broke into the safe two days later, before they could remove it from the building.

Hembury says the village board declined to renew the Montgomery Advisory Board’s contract, which had expired years earlier, and says the safe was open when he arrived to check on a new staff member.

“I said, 'You know what, this has to be secured. Put it over there. I will bring it up to Village Hall.'”

Hembury says the Montgomery Advisory Board’s contract wasn’t renewed due to mismanagement, which its members deny, and says the group called the police falsely claiming he stole money from it.

The controversy isn’t the only recent upset when it comes to Hembury’s reign.

Dozens of residents were seen on village video being turned away from Village Hall Sept. 17 during a packed, standing room only board meeting due to occupancy limitations. Residents were heard on the recording yelling to stop the meeting and demanding it be held at the senior center, where a larger number of residents can be accommodated.

“Really, it’s only 19 people, villagers, who can come in there and view a meeting,” says Karen DeCosta.

DeCosta and other residents say Village Hall isn’t big enough anymore for board meetings and claim new local laws about flags, migrants and people sleeping in cars and tents are taking the focus off more important issues.

“They seem to be non-effective. None of these laws are really affecting positive change,” says resident James Kiernan.

Hembury says a larger space for meetings is in the works and that most people agree with how the village is being run.

“We are still the best place around," says Hembry.

Village of Montgomery officials are expected to discuss a proposed law banning people from sleeping in their cars and tents Tuesday night.

News 12 is told state police were called to investigate the alleged safe theft, but they didn’t return our call for information.

Top Stories

01:48
Screenshot 2026-09-16 053925

Road rage incident leads to attempted murder charge after chaotic altercation on I-87

01:39
HV Rain Day Night

Midweek warmup with chances of rain in the Hudson Valley

00:38
Screenshot 2026-09-16 053254

Order of protection issued for baby in White Plains newborn abandonment case

00:33
Screenshot 2026-09-16 053910

Federal appeals court revives free speech lawsuit against Croton-Harmon school district

01:24
916whatscooking_2026-09-16-05-51-27

What’s Cooking: Spaghetti muffins

00:24
Screenshot 2026-09-16 053153

Undercover child exploitation sting leads to arrests in New York and New Jersey

02:11
gregpkg0915_2026-09-15-21-55-49

Retired Mount Vernon firefighter defends outburst at protesters near 9/11 anniversary ceremony

00:30
Screenshot 2026-09-15 210849

Yonkers 15-year-old indicted in connection to fatal August shooting

01:56
RTREGWCHVNewFoodPantryMPalmer9pm_2026-09-15-21-20-32

Meals on Main Street opens second kitchen in Mount Kisco, as need continues to grow

00:29
WCCT hospital runaway 0915_2026-09-15-16-48-40

Police: 17-year-old who ran away from New York hospital found in Wilton

01:29
blaise food poisoning

Orange County investigates possible mass food poisoning among employees after emergency drill

00:26
Screenshot 2026-09-15 163146

New law in Westchester closes loophole on flavored vape ban

01:02
RTREGWCHVRCCNewNursingLabDCarusoVOSOTSG001

Rockland Community College opens new nursing simulation lab

00:35
health0915_2026-09-15-18-54-16

Doctors: Burning candles are among hidden air-quality dangers at home

00:27
RGDollyBuffaloKK_2026-09-15-16-59-44

Amenia farm names baby water buffalo after Dolly Parton, her husband

00:19
Screenshot 2026-09-15 163427

Man found dead in Ulster County creek after possible drowning

01:05
Abused Dogs Up for Adoption 0915_2026-09-15-21-30-16

Dogs seen tied to moving car in viral video now ready for adoption after Hudson Valley rehab

01:34
Screenshot 2026-09-15 061311

2026-27 Snowfall Outlook: The El Niño recipe, Part 2

APNickReinerAvoidsDeathPenalty

Nick Reiner avoids death penalty over his parents’ killings but still faces life in prison

00:20
OperationSanta_2026-09-15-12-21-05

'Tis the season! Children can start sending letters to Santa as USPS opens annual program

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices