Judge rules in favor of owner in cupcake shop shutdown

A judge ruled in favor of Cupcake Cutie Boutique, a cupcake shop that was deemed unsafe and dangerous by the city of Mount Vernon.

News 12 Staff

Jan 5, 2019, 4:22 PM

Updated 2,027 days ago

Share:

A judge ruled in favor of Cupcake Cutie Boutique, a cupcake shop that was deemed unsafe and dangerous by the city of Mount Vernon.
The store had been in business for three years but in August, the city ordered it to be shut down. The store owners fought back against the claims in court.
Miesha Starkly, one of the owners, says she believes the city tried to shut down her store due to her stepfather being a vocal critic of Mayor Richard Thomas.
Starkly's stepfather, Damon Jones, is a publisher of Black Westchester.
The judge says the city couldn't explain why it had deemed the store unsafe, and ordered the city to issue a temporary certificate of tenancy until Jan. 10.
If the city refuses to follow orders, then the commissioner must come before the court.
The store has stayed open throughout the court case and a permanent certificate of tenancy is expected to be issued after Jan. 10.
News 12 Westchester reached out to Thomas for comment.


More from News 12
1:22
Police: 1 hospitalized in afternoon Mount Vernon shooting

Police: 1 hospitalized in afternoon Mount Vernon shooting

2:00
Warm and humid with possible showers today, nicer weather coming in 48 hours!

Warm and humid with possible showers today, nicer weather coming in 48 hours!

1:42
North Rockland man to compete in Olympic Games, representing Ireland in shot put

North Rockland man to compete in Olympic Games, representing Ireland in shot put

1:43
Poughkeepsie residents fight to keep adult shelter out of neighborhood

Poughkeepsie residents fight to keep adult shelter out of neighborhood

1:36
Greenburgh to fix one of its worst intersections

Greenburgh to fix one of its worst intersections

1:23
Officials criticize Social Security Administration for sudden closure of Newburgh offices

Officials criticize Social Security Administration for sudden closure of Newburgh offices

0:30
Residents question water tower repairs in Unionville after county violation notice

Residents question water tower repairs in Unionville after county violation notice

0:22
North Salem School Board places superintendent on administrative leave

North Salem School Board places superintendent on administrative leave

0:28
Wallkill man arrested for DWI, drug possession in Ulster County

Wallkill man arrested for DWI, drug possession in Ulster County

0:37
$5,000 reward offered for information on suspect in fatal shooting

$5,000 reward offered for information on suspect in fatal shooting

1:05
Headlines: Cocaine sentencing in Port Jervis, barn fire death, cause of plane crash released

Headlines: Cocaine sentencing in Port Jervis, barn fire death, cause of plane crash released

4:23
Sen. Bob Menendez to resign from office Aug. 20 following corruption conviction

Sen. Bob Menendez to resign from office Aug. 20 following corruption conviction

1:49
Mamaroneck tackles chronic flooding with new study and projects

Mamaroneck tackles chronic flooding with new study and projects

0:28
Susan Siegel projected winner in Yorktown council election

Susan Siegel projected winner in Yorktown council election

0:26
Woman stabbed in Yonkers domestic dispute, suspect arrested

Woman stabbed in Yonkers domestic dispute, suspect arrested

0:17
20-story mural completes transformation of downtown New Rochelle

20-story mural completes transformation of downtown New Rochelle

0:14
LEGOLAND New York seeks master model builder in 'Brick Factor Model Builder' competition

LEGOLAND New York seeks master model builder in 'Brick Factor Model Builder' competition

1:22
How are young Hudson Valley voters feeling about the possibility of Kamala Harris as the Democratic nominee for president?

How are young Hudson Valley voters feeling about the possibility of Kamala Harris as the Democratic nominee for president?

2:24
Tackling flooding in the Town of Mamaroneck, engineering consultant looks into options

Tackling flooding in the Town of Mamaroneck, engineering consultant looks into options

1:47
'I don't know what the answer is.' Newburgh residents may have to live with dangerous intersection indefinitely

'I don't know what the answer is.' Newburgh residents may have to live with dangerous intersection indefinitely