Families celebrate after New York legalizes paid surrogacy after 28 years

Two Brooklyn families who dreamed of having children are now one step closer after New York legalized paid surrogacy after 28 years.

News 12 Staff

Apr 5, 2020, 11:08 AM

Updated 1,494 days ago

Share:

Two Brooklyn families who dreamed of having children are now one step closer after New York legalized paid surrogacy after 28 years.
Cynara Charles-Pierre says that she had a 4-year-old daughter through surrogacy. Cynara says she went through an agency in New Jersey.
Another parent through surrogacy, Dennis Williams, says his friend donated her eggs for him to create his family and he was linked to a surrogate through a friend.
Both parents says they were blindsided that gestational pregnancy was illegal in New York and had to start their family in a different state.
The battle was personal as well for William and Elizabeth Stern and their surrogate, Mary Beth Whitehead. The highly publicized "Baby M" custody case in 1987 would be the catalyst for New York banning the practice.
Whitehead fought for parental rights of the child she carried for the Stern family, using her egg through a traditional surrogacy contract. A judge denied the surrogate custody and granted custody to William.
In 1992, New York made the decision to ban the practice.
Gov. Andrew Cuomo added gestational surrogacy to the 2021 fiscal year budget, ending the battle after 28 years.
Cuomo is championing what he's calling the Love Makes a Family campaign, or the Child-Parent Security Act.
TV host Andy Cohen wrote on Instagram, "The passage of the Child-Parent Security Act means thousands of New Yorkers who struggle with infertility, cancer survivors, and LGBTQ will have a chance of a family."
Before it's passing, the proposal to legalize gestational surrogacy drew criticism from conservatives and feminists. Many cited the harm it can do to financially struggling women.
It wasn't until 2010 that the idea to life the surrogacy ban was introduced to the state legislature by Assemblywoman Amy Paulin.
Her bill cleared the Senate after teaming up the Sen. Brad Holyman, but it never passed her own chamber. Sen. Liz Krueger voted "no" for the bill last year, being the only Democrat to do so.
Krueger's proposed legislation was dubbed the compromise bill, which included mandates that would subject intended parents to background checks, have a surrogate provide a written declaration giving up parental rights and strict guidelines for agencies and clinics.
It's not clear how much of Krueger or Paulin's bill are included in the recently passed legislation.
Details have not been fully revealed yet, but the budget states it will provide strong protections for both intended parents and surrogates, informed consent every step of the way and create a surrogate bill of rights.
Surrogates will be able to make their own health care decisions, grant them access to health insurance and independent legal counsel paid for by the intended parents and establish parenthood when one of the individuals is a non-biological parent, known as second parent adoption.
Dr. Briana Rudkick says clinics like the Columbia University fertility center are ready to start helping New York residents who want to start their families through surrogacy.


More from News 12
1:40
Opening statements begin in Town of Wallkill murder-for-hire trial

Opening statements begin in Town of Wallkill murder-for-hire trial

2:18
Summerlike afternoon with highs in 80, rain and big cool down coming

Summerlike afternoon with highs in 80, rain and big cool down coming

1:58
4 teens face hate crime charges in Ramapo, accused of antisemitic drive-by harassment

4 teens face hate crime charges in Ramapo, accused of antisemitic drive-by harassment

0:27
Rye police: Car burglary highlights need to lock vehicles

Rye police: Car burglary highlights need to lock vehicles

0:48
Rockland community unites to commemorate Holocaust Remembrance Day

Rockland community unites to commemorate Holocaust Remembrance Day

1:46
Fire officials: Fatal Ossining fire doesn't appear to be suspicious

Fire officials: Fatal Ossining fire doesn't appear to be suspicious

0:30
‘We are heartbroken.’ Loved ones search for answers in case of missing New Paltz woman

‘We are heartbroken.’ Loved ones search for answers in case of missing New Paltz woman

0:19
Rabies alert issued in Sullivan County after fox tests positive

Rabies alert issued in Sullivan County after fox tests positive

1:14
Headlines: Woman stabbed in White Plains, fatal crash on I-84, body of missing guardsman found

Headlines: Woman stabbed in White Plains, fatal crash on I-84, body of missing guardsman found

0:20
Parents, NYCLU rally in Albany to demand changes in E. Ramapo schools

Parents, NYCLU rally in Albany to demand changes in E. Ramapo schools

0:40
New York honors fallen police officers with memorial wall dedication

New York honors fallen police officers with memorial wall dedication

0:28
Trial of Wallkill man suspected of hiring someone to kill his neighbor begins today

Trial of Wallkill man suspected of hiring someone to kill his neighbor begins today

0:32
SUNY Purchase agrees to suspend disciplinary consequences for protester arrested during campus demonstrations

SUNY Purchase agrees to suspend disciplinary consequences for protester arrested during campus demonstrations

0:38
Local thrift store hits $4 million in charitable giving to Northern Westchester hospital

Local thrift store hits $4 million in charitable giving to Northern Westchester hospital

0:31
Orange County school districts poised to implement wards for school board elections

Orange County school districts poised to implement wards for school board elections

0:30
New Rochelle maintains current elementary school start times despite cost concerns

New Rochelle maintains current elementary school start times despite cost concerns

0:21
Small business owners recognized for contributions during Asian Pacific American Heritage Month

Small business owners recognized for contributions during Asian Pacific American Heritage Month

1:08
Sleepy Hollow music festival to debut with indie rock band Cold War Kids headlining

Sleepy Hollow music festival to debut with indie rock band Cold War Kids headlining

1:43
Garden Guide: These plants repel weeds and are a natural fertilizer!

Garden Guide: These plants repel weeds and are a natural fertilizer!

0:22
Trocheck's power-play goal lifts Rangers to 4-3 win over Hurricanes in 2OT for 2-0 series lead

Trocheck's power-play goal lifts Rangers to 4-3 win over Hurricanes in 2OT for 2-0 series lead