'It is discrimination by the pen.' Advocates worry Brookhaven's redistricting proposal could weaken vote from Black and brown communities

The council district maps have to change because populations shifted when the census was counted in 2020.

News 12 Staff

Sep 29, 2022, 12:29 AM

Updated 582 days ago

Share:

Some advocates are concerned proposed changes to the Town of Brookhaven's council districts could weaken the minority vote.
The council district maps have to change because populations shifted when the census was counted in 2020.
One of the districts will get larger while the other will get smaller.
Districts 2 and 6 are the ones that need to change. However, District 4, which contains some predominantly Black and brown communities would extend northeast into Ridge, a mostly white community.
That would cause the vote for those communities to be weakened, according to some in the area.
"It is discrimination by the pen," says Brookhaven Town NAACP President Georgette Grier-Key.
She says the two areas are completely different if you look at the socio-economics, which is the classic case for gerrymandering. Grier-Key says District 2 should be larger and District 6 should be smaller.
"We don't want council districts based on race - we want council districts based on communities," Grier-Key says.
The town is pushing against that criticism.
A Brookhaven town spokesperson says the redistricting is a fair, open and transparent process that unifies many neighborhoods that have been split by previous plans.
In a statement, the town spokesperson wrote, "The map before the town board on Thursday makes no changes for more than 90% of residents...The redistricting process conducted by Brookhaven was fair, open and transparent, with more than a dozen public hearings..."
It is possible that the town council will vote on the proposed districts on Thursday. The board has until Dec. 15 to choose a new map and those boundaries will remain in effect for the next decade.


More from News 12
3:46
Students at SUNY Purchase join pro-Palestinian protest movement

Students at SUNY Purchase join pro-Palestinian protest movement

2:04
Cooler day for the Hudson Valley with temps in the 60s; tracking rain for Sunday

Cooler day for the Hudson Valley with temps in the 60s; tracking rain for Sunday

WATCH LIVE: Bridge over section of I-95 is being demolished due to damage from truck fire

WATCH LIVE: Bridge over section of I-95 is being demolished due to damage from truck fire

Police: Child sustained minor injuries when struck by on-duty Monticello police officer

Police: Child sustained minor injuries when struck by on-duty Monticello police officer

0:33
Volunteer firefighter dies in Tuxedo motorcycle crash

Volunteer firefighter dies in Tuxedo motorcycle crash

0:30
Ex-Brewster village officer sentenced for protecting prostitution businesses

Ex-Brewster village officer sentenced for protecting prostitution businesses

2:48
Pro-Palestinian encampment remains at SUNY New Paltz campus

Pro-Palestinian encampment remains at SUNY New Paltz campus

0:32
Rep. Ryan calls for planned Central Hudson rate increase to be denied

Rep. Ryan calls for planned Central Hudson rate increase to be denied

0:21
Yonkers Art unveils 2 new exhibits ahead of weekend festival

Yonkers Art unveils 2 new exhibits ahead of weekend festival

1:26
Look up! Annual Eta Aquarid meteor shower peaks early Sunday morning

Look up! Annual Eta Aquarid meteor shower peaks early Sunday morning

0:33
Dobbs Ferry man facing federal charges of illegal possession of firearms, ammunition

Dobbs Ferry man facing federal charges of illegal possession of firearms, ammunition

1:47
EXCLUSIVE: Ex-Monticello officer who admitted to sex assault of underage teen reinstated to department after arrest

EXCLUSIVE: Ex-Monticello officer who admitted to sex assault of underage teen reinstated to department after arrest

0:36
Police: Woman arrested in connection to student brawl outside Yonkers school

Police: Woman arrested in connection to student brawl outside Yonkers school

1:44
Poughkeepsie leaders ask public for help to find troubled teens before tragedy strikes

Poughkeepsie leaders ask public for help to find troubled teens before tragedy strikes

1:02
Ribbon-cutting ceremony held for completion of New Rochelle affordable housing development

Ribbon-cutting ceremony held for completion of New Rochelle affordable housing development

0:32
Bedford School District to receive more money aid, boost in funding from state

Bedford School District to receive more money aid, boost in funding from state

0:30
Blooming Grove highway worker seriously injured during tree removal

Blooming Grove highway worker seriously injured during tree removal

0:23
Overnight road work to close Exit 7 on Cross County Parkway in Westchester

Overnight road work to close Exit 7 on Cross County Parkway in Westchester

0:28
SPCA Westchester launches first mobile adoption unit

SPCA Westchester launches first mobile adoption unit

1:44
Exploring the Westchester children's museum: A journey of play and discovery

Exploring the Westchester children's museum: A journey of play and discovery