NY judge rules against Rockland County measles ban

A New York judge ruled against Rockland County Friday afternoon after the county placed a ban preventing children unvaccinated against measles from being in public places.

News 12 Staff

Apr 6, 2019, 11:18 AM

Updated 1,847 days ago

Share:

A New York judge ruled against Rockland County Friday, halting the county's ban preventing children unvaccinated against measles from being in public places.
Rockland County declared a state of emergency over the measles outbreak, which was in effect for 10 days.
Some parents challenged the county's emergency order, arguing that it violated their First Amendment right to exercise their freedom of religion.
"We're gratified that the judge has wisely granted these children to go back to school," says Rita Palma, of the New York Alliance for Vaccine Rights.
They say the ban would make it so unvaccinated children would be prevented from going to church or synagogue, especially during Easter or Passover.
Acting Supreme Court Justice Rolf Thorson says that the county's order didn't rise to the level of a disaster required by law.
County Executive Ed Day says he declared the state of emergency after he saw a spike in measles cases since October. He says the number of confirmed cases went up to 167.
"The read I get on this is that, we have to wait until it's much worse, and while that may be legally sufficient, I think it's very wrong-headed," says Day.
The attorney for the parents says they're pleased about the ruling, but Day says this is a setback for the county trying to end the outbreak of measles.
In a statement, Day says, "My administration refuses to sit idly by while those in Rockland are put at risk. All should know that my executive team will meet with our legal and health professionals Monday morning and identify potential new strategies."
The ban is lifted temporarily as the county reviews its declaration. All parties involved are scheduled to return to court on April 19.


More from News 12
0:32
Kingston man charged in barbershop stabbing

Kingston man charged in barbershop stabbing

1:30
Chilly temps in the Hudson Valley will warm up as afternoon sunshine rolls in

Chilly temps in the Hudson Valley will warm up as afternoon sunshine rolls in

2:04
Movie theater experience: A close look at the Jacob Burns Film Center in Pleasantville

Movie theater experience: A close look at the Jacob Burns Film Center in Pleasantville

1:35
 White Plains community memorializes impactful couple as part of 41st Arbor Day celebration

White Plains community memorializes impactful couple as part of 41st Arbor Day celebration

0:21
Funeral held for Westchester correction officer killed in Scarsdale motorcycle crash

Funeral held for Westchester correction officer killed in Scarsdale motorcycle crash

0:31
Police: 18-year-old Washingtonville man with autism has gone missing

Police: 18-year-old Washingtonville man with autism has gone missing

0:23
New Korean-style fried chicken restaurant opens in Mahopac

New Korean-style fried chicken restaurant opens in Mahopac

2:16
New Rochelle teacher receives birthday surprise from students, colleagues

New Rochelle teacher receives birthday surprise from students, colleagues

1:23
Pro-Palestinian demonstrators rally in Irvington during President Biden's visits to Westchester

Pro-Palestinian demonstrators rally in Irvington during President Biden's visits to Westchester

0:26
Hudson Valley communities receive bronze Climate Smart Certification

Hudson Valley communities receive bronze Climate Smart Certification

0:23
Rockland County sues New York state over when elections can be held

Rockland County sues New York state over when elections can be held

0:21
Greenwood Lake Board of Trustees appoints interim mayor

Greenwood Lake Board of Trustees appoints interim mayor

0:23
Police: 18-year-old facing charges in Walden shooting

Police: 18-year-old facing charges in Walden shooting

0:48
President Biden announces future opening of upstate microchip factory

President Biden announces future opening of upstate microchip factory

1:53
Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

0:21
Rockland County DA: Haverstraw man pleads guilty in sexual abuse of 2 children

Rockland County DA: Haverstraw man pleads guilty in sexual abuse of 2 children

0:51
Indian Point oversight board, Holtec discuss decommissioning options of former nuclear plant

Indian Point oversight board, Holtec discuss decommissioning options of former nuclear plant

0:47
State police: DNA sample from human remains found does not match profile of missing Putnam teen

State police: DNA sample from human remains found does not match profile of missing Putnam teen

0:31
New mural of Yonkers hip-hop legend Mary J. Blige unveiled at Palisade Towers

New mural of Yonkers hip-hop legend Mary J. Blige unveiled at Palisade Towers

0:35
Police find evidence in burglary while investigating a domestic dispute in Monroe

Police find evidence in burglary while investigating a domestic dispute in Monroe