News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys
Partly Cloudy Night
58°
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys

'Montauk Mary,' found slain in 1978, among unidentified cold case victims to be named

"Montauk Mary" was found face-up with bullet wounds in East Overlook Park off Montauk Highway in 1978.

Karina Kovac

•

Nov 10, 2026, 5:23 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Six more unidentified people tied to Suffolk County cold cases will soon be known through genetic genealogy by the Suffolk County District Attorney’s Cold Case Task Force, including a woman known only as "Montauk Mary."

Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney and Suffolk Police Department Commissioner Kevin Catalina on Thursday will publicly announce the identities in cases spanning five decades, with the oldest case dating to 1976.

"Montauk Mary" was found face-up with bullet wounds in East Overlook Park off Montauk Highway in 1978.

Investigators determined she had been shot four times, once in the chest and three times in the legs, and likely died just hours before she was found.

Authorities believed the woman to be in her 60s, about 5 feet tall and weighing roughly 200 pounds. She was wearing a plaid tweed coat, a multicolored dress and orange slippers, but had no clothing tags or undergarments.

Last year, the task force worked with a Suffolk County police forensic artist to create an updated sketch of what "Montauk Mary" may have looked like before her death in hopes of learning her identity.

The identifications come on the heels of other breakthroughs this year in decades-old cases involving deceased infants, where genetic genealogy testing led investigators to arrests years later.

In late October, a Virginia woman was arrested and extradited. She is accused of killing her baby inside a movie theater bathroom 30 years ago.

Another case was earlier this year in February, where a woman was arrested in connection to a 1993 cold case where an infant was discovered dead by highway workers inside a trash bag.

The same testing technique was used in the Gilgo Beach serial killer investigation to help connect Rex Heuermann to his victims years after their murders.

Top Stories

blaise eagle

Ulster County EMTs help rescue injured bald eagle in Newburgh

01:03
HV STORMWATCH

STORM WATCH: Hudson Valley will see pockets of heavy rain starting tomorrow, with wet snow in highest elevations

00:28
Screenshot 2026-11-11 133932

Written threat discovered inside Hyde Park middle school

31792bea-db16-4762-9ec0-25336087dda6

Veterans bring lessons of courage, duty and sacrifice to Iona Prep students

Article 243275 Thumbnail

From free meals to free haircuts! Here are some popular Veterans Day deals and discounts

Casting Call Clapboard

Casting underway for Nick Jonas-led Christmas movie to be filmed in NJ

00:18
Screenshot 2026-11-11 062703

Students unload hundreds of turkeys for Westchester families in need

00:30
fraud scheme

Westchester man charged in multimillion-dollar real estate fraud scheme

00:43
11112026WCai_2026-11-11-06-26-15

New York launches first-in-the-nation AI research institute to test powerful systems

01:15
1111whatscooking_2026-11-11-08-13-00

What’s Cooking: Pumpkin ravioli with autumn sauce

01:28
111026WC No Parking

Yonkers residents upset after 'No Parking Anytime' signs appear without warning

00:32
111measles1_2026-11-11-05-18-35

United States on brink of losing measles elimination status

Vote 2026

VOTE 2026: Westchester Election Results

00:54
ballotupdate1011_2026-11-10-21-37-45

Board of Elections: All emergency ballots cast on Election Day in Westchester County have been scanned

Missing Voices

Homeless Youth in Crisis: The Missing Voices

00:29
RTREGWCHVHydeParkFatalDWISentenceVO9pmRDX

Hyde Park man sentenced to prison following guilty plea in fatal 2025 DWAI crash

00:26
gavel-generic-court-thumbnail

DA: Convicted Spring Valley felon admits to owning loaded gun without permit

RTREGWCHVMVTennisSettlementVO9pm

City of Mount Vernon, tennis center operator reach settlement over deflated bubble

00:25
RTREGWCHVPutnamExecClaimsVictory11102026VO9pm

Vote 2026: Incumbent Putnam County executive declares victory in close reelection battle

01:21
blaise middletown football

Perfect season, crushed dreams: Middletown varsity football team ousted over eligibility blunder

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices