Judge: Man who bought $30K painting for $200 cannot move, sell it

A judge is set to decide the true owner of a painting that the former owner says was sold by mistake.

News 12 Staff

Nov 22, 2019, 10:36 PM

Updated 1,676 days ago

Share:

A judge is set to decide the true owner of a painting that the former owner says was sold by mistake.
The controversy centers around a 20th century painting by American impressionist Aldro Thompson Hibbard. The painting is worth up to $30,000 but was sold for just $200.
On Friday, a judge decided the person in possession of the painting cannot move or sell it, as ownership is disputed.
The painting was owned by 88-year-old Helen Guistino, of Thornwood, who contends her son sold it without her permission. Dr. Sydney Hiller, who Gustino's attorney says is a collector and dealer in fine arts and antiques, bought the painting at a moving sale.
The painting now resides at Hiller's Briarcliff home hanging on a wall, where it will likely stay as the two parties dispute ownership.
Hiller's attorney didn't show up to court Friday, but said by phone they believe this is an unfortunate case and that her client is being vilified for simply purchasing the painting.
Dr. Hiller was also ordered to raise his liability insurance on the painting from $15,000 to $30,000.
 


More from News 12
2:44
Vote 2024: Primary day features heavyweight battle between Bowman and Latimer

Vote 2024: Primary day features heavyweight battle between Bowman and Latimer

1:53
Temperatures rise Tuesday in the Hudson Valley; tracking storms on Wednesday

Temperatures rise Tuesday in the Hudson Valley; tracking storms on Wednesday

1:59
Fallen tree destroys home in North Salem; homeowner ‘thankful’ to be alive

Fallen tree destroys home in North Salem; homeowner ‘thankful’ to be alive

0:28
Peekskill man faces felony assault charges connected to stabbing outside Cortlandt bar

Peekskill man faces felony assault charges connected to stabbing outside Cortlandt bar

1:44
Storms pummel northern Westchester, about 30 downed trees in Somers

Storms pummel northern Westchester, about 30 downed trees in Somers

Bronx DA: Yonkers mother who left children in hot car won’t be prosecuted

Bronx DA: Yonkers mother who left children in hot car won’t be prosecuted

0:34
Man convicted of killing 76-year-old man in Newburgh

Man convicted of killing 76-year-old man in Newburgh

1:44
Elevator in 7-story Nyack apartment building broken for past 2 weeks

Elevator in 7-story Nyack apartment building broken for past 2 weeks

1:45
‘Listen to your body.’ Heart patient from Saugerties reunites with doctors who saved his life

‘Listen to your body.’ Heart patient from Saugerties reunites with doctors who saved his life

1:07
Caught on camera: Intense storm downs trees in Chester

Caught on camera: Intense storm downs trees in Chester

1:51
Downed tree closes portion of Midland Avenue in Yonkers

Downed tree closes portion of Midland Avenue in Yonkers

1:07
Storm knocks out power to thousands of homes and businesses across the Hudson Valley

Storm knocks out power to thousands of homes and businesses across the Hudson Valley

2:15
Kane in Your Corner: How to avoid scams using AI to target victims

Kane in Your Corner: How to avoid scams using AI to target victims

0:35
Headlines: Multicar crash in Newburgh, Poughkeepsie shooting

Headlines: Multicar crash in Newburgh, Poughkeepsie shooting

0:26
Black history gets preserved through photographer's lens in Yonkers

Black history gets preserved through photographer's lens in Yonkers

0:35
Yonkers firefighters compete for spot on 2025 calendar to benefit scholarships

Yonkers firefighters compete for spot on 2025 calendar to benefit scholarships

0:29
Irvington celebrates Juneteenth by honoring legacy of icon Madam C.J.. Walker

Irvington celebrates Juneteenth by honoring legacy of icon Madam C.J.. Walker

0:37
Rockland firefighters honor 95-year-old veteran with street dedication

Rockland firefighters honor 95-year-old veteran with street dedication

1:59
Candlelight vigil remembers mother and 6-year-old son killed by school bus in Mamaroneck

Candlelight vigil remembers mother and 6-year-old son killed by school bus in Mamaroneck

3:04
Crews begin demolition on partially collapsed building in Yonkers

Crews begin demolition on partially collapsed building in Yonkers