'It just makes no sense.' Sister seeks answers on missing man found dead in Sullivan County swamp

The father of two is from Port Jervis but was living in Glen Spey when he was last seen alive by a friend.

Blaise Gomez

Apr 12, 2023, 4:20 PM

Updated 471 days ago

Share:

Authorities have not yet said what caused the death of a missing man found dead in a swamp in the Town of Forrestburgh last week.
Rescuers had tried to find him for days. It's a mystery Harold Hoyt's sister is desperate to solve.  
"It doesn't make sense how one goes in, and one never comes out," said Jennifer Nicholas.
Nicholas says her brother's friend told authorities he suffered a medical emergency after their car broke down when they got separated. 
"Their tire was flat, and they had no gas," said Nicholas. "He got sick and had a seizure. My brother left and told his friend, 'I'm going to get you help.'"
The father of two is from Port Jervis but was living in Glen Spey when he was last seen alive by his friend, who has not been named by authorities.
Officials say his friend reported him missing on March 31.
Their car broke down on a logging trail off Galligan Road near the Camp Turrell Boy Scout Reservation, according to the Sullivan County Sheriff's Office.
Officials say Hoyt's friend made it to a nearby road, but that Hoyt apparently became lost in the woods.
"They began a search party immediately. We searched for him from sunup to sundown every day," said Nicholas.
The father of two was found deceased after an exhaustive search seven days later, on April 7, in a wooded swamp.
"I can't even begin to describe what we feel right now," said Nicholas. "It's devastation. The whole thing has just been a nightmare."
Authorities are still investigating the tragedy, and an autopsy was performed Monday to find out how Hoyt died.
"My brother knew his way around the woods. He knew survival skills. It just makes no sense to me," said Nicholas.
Wake services for Harold Hoyt will be held at the Gray-Parker Funeral Home in Port Jervis from 4-7 p.m. Thursday.


More from News 12
1:52
Hudson Valley doctors warn of listeria dangers following multi-state outbreak

Hudson Valley doctors warn of listeria dangers following multi-state outbreak

2:04
Sunny skies and warm temps for Saturday in the Hudson Valley

Sunny skies and warm temps for Saturday in the Hudson Valley

0:38
Multimillion-dollar transformation on the way for sections of Hudson Valley

Multimillion-dollar transformation on the way for sections of Hudson Valley

0:49
New basketball documentary film 'The Process' has ties to Westchester

New basketball documentary film 'The Process' has ties to Westchester

0:49
Olympic watch party in Pomona cheers on Rockland athletes

Olympic watch party in Pomona cheers on Rockland athletes

0:32
Veteran firefighter who suffered stroke receives warm welcome home

Veteran firefighter who suffered stroke receives warm welcome home

0:17
Yorktown police sergeant celebrates final walkout following 2 decades of service

Yorktown police sergeant celebrates final walkout following 2 decades of service

1:40
Lithium-ion battery fire blamed for closure of Newburgh tailor shop

Lithium-ion battery fire blamed for closure of Newburgh tailor shop

0:52
Slate Hill family of 5 loses home in afternoon blaze

Slate Hill family of 5 loses home in afternoon blaze

0:37
2 people charged in Middletown narcotics; firearms bust

2 people charged in Middletown narcotics; firearms bust

1:30
Motorcycle, van crash in Greenburgh causes serious injuries

Motorcycle, van crash in Greenburgh causes serious injuries

0:56
News 12 probes mystery cloud traced to Orange County & seen throughout tri-state area

News 12 probes mystery cloud traced to Orange County & seen throughout tri-state area

1:02
Hillcrest Fire Department receives 2,000 cans of drinking water, courtesy of Anheuser-Busch

Hillcrest Fire Department receives 2,000 cans of drinking water, courtesy of Anheuser-Busch

1:37
Storm Watch Team Meteorologist Skyler Harman strikes down lightning myths

Storm Watch Team Meteorologist Skyler Harman strikes down lightning myths

2:33
Can swimming become dangerous due to extremely high water surface temperatures?

Can swimming become dangerous due to extremely high water surface temperatures?

0:32
NYC officials: Westchester caseworker’s death ruled a homicide

NYC officials: Westchester caseworker’s death ruled a homicide

0:40
State, federal lawmakers introduce legislation to shorten funding gap for World Trade Center Health Program

State, federal lawmakers introduce legislation to shorten funding gap for World Trade Center Health Program

0:34
Ex Frito-Lay employee files defamation lawsuit against PepsiCo claiming he invented ‘Flamin’ Hot Cheetos

Ex Frito-Lay employee files defamation lawsuit against PepsiCo claiming he invented ‘Flamin’ Hot Cheetos

0:40
Executive orders still in place preventing Rockland County and Orange County hotels from converting into migrant shelters

Executive orders still in place preventing Rockland County and Orange County hotels from converting into migrant shelters

0:34
Finger in salad lawsuit against Chop’t discontinued

Finger in salad lawsuit against Chop’t discontinued