FBI issues subpoena to seize materials collected at home of Monsey stabbing suspect

The FBI was at the Goshen office of Grafton Thomas’ attorney Friday to seize materials that Michael Sussman collected from a home where the Monsey stabbing suspect lived.

News 12 Staff

Jan 3, 2020, 8:01 PM

Updated 1,663 days ago

Share:

The FBI was at the Goshen office of Grafton Thomas’ attorney Friday to seize materials that Michael Sussman collected from a home where the Monsey stabbing suspect lived.
The FBI issued a subpoena to seize material Sussman says he took out of the Wurtsboro cabin of Thomas’ mother, where Thomas lived for several years before moving out in 2018.
But Sussman says he has a responsibility to his client to chronicle all the evidence before he hands it over to federal authorities.
To date, Sussman says his forensic team hasn't found anything suggesting Thomas is anti-Semitic in the items taken from the Wurtsboro home, which include books, journals, a cellphone and a computer.
"We found one swastika in the material, and that was surrounded by writing that said to the effect, ‘How did a symbol of prosperity become corrupted into a symbol of destruction?’" says Sussman.
Sussman says he's filing an appeal with a federal judge that would allow him to finish chronicling the evidence before it can be inspected.
Sussman says he visited Thomas in jail just moments before federal agents arrived at his law office. He says Thomas has deteriorated since earlier the week and is now "entirely confused and relatively incoherent."
 
 


More from News 12
0:37
$5,000 reward offered for information on suspect in fatal shooting

$5,000 reward offered for information on suspect in fatal shooting

1:47
Warm and humid with possible showers today, nicer weather coming in 48 hours!

Warm and humid with possible showers today, nicer weather coming in 48 hours!

1:05
Headlines: Cocaine sentencing in Port Jervis, barn fire death, cause of plane crash released

Headlines: Cocaine sentencing in Port Jervis, barn fire death, cause of plane crash released

4:23
Sen. Bob Menendez to resign from office Aug. 20 following corruption conviction

Sen. Bob Menendez to resign from office Aug. 20 following corruption conviction

1:52
Mamaroneck tackles chronic flooding with new study and projects

Mamaroneck tackles chronic flooding with new study and projects

0:28
Susan Siegel projected winner in Yorktown council election

Susan Siegel projected winner in Yorktown council election

0:26
Woman stabbed in Yonkers domestic dispute, suspect arrested

Woman stabbed in Yonkers domestic dispute, suspect arrested

0:17
20-story mural completes transformation of downtown New Rochelle

20-story mural completes transformation of downtown New Rochelle

0:14
LEGOLAND New York seeks master model builder in 'Brick Factor Model Builder' competition

LEGOLAND New York seeks master model builder in 'Brick Factor Model Builder' competition

1:38
Police: Man arrested for slashing woman during domestic dispute in Yonkers

Police: Man arrested for slashing woman during domestic dispute in Yonkers

1:22
How are young Hudson Valley voters feeling about the possibility of Kamala Harris as the Democratic nominee for president?

How are young Hudson Valley voters feeling about the possibility of Kamala Harris as the Democratic nominee for president?

2:24
Tackling flooding in the Town of Mamaroneck, engineering consultant looks into options

Tackling flooding in the Town of Mamaroneck, engineering consultant looks into options

1:48
A look back at President Biden, VP Harris' visits to the Hudson Valley

A look back at President Biden, VP Harris' visits to the Hudson Valley

1:47
'I don't know what the answer is.' Newburgh residents may have to live with dangerous intersection indefinitely

'I don't know what the answer is.' Newburgh residents may have to live with dangerous intersection indefinitely

1:29
Oklahoma woman sentenced to 4-12 years for fatal drunk-driving crash in Newburgh

Oklahoma woman sentenced to 4-12 years for fatal drunk-driving crash in Newburgh

Special election in Yorktown will fill vacant Town Council seat

Special election in Yorktown will fill vacant Town Council seat

0:48
Made in the Hudson Valley: 'Mister Croissant' bakery brings world-class pastries to Middletown

Made in the Hudson Valley: 'Mister Croissant' bakery brings world-class pastries to Middletown

0:43
Secret Service director steps down after assassination attempt against ex-President Trump at rally

Secret Service director steps down after assassination attempt against ex-President Trump at rally

0:21
$17 million awarded to repair Callicoon Bridge in Sullivan County

$17 million awarded to repair Callicoon Bridge in Sullivan County

0:28
Orange County man fatally struck in hit-and-run crash in the Bronx; man charged

Orange County man fatally struck in hit-and-run crash in the Bronx; man charged