Copy-Budget bill likely would end Supreme Court email search case

The budget bill before Congress includes an update to federal law that makes clear that authorities with a warrant can obtain emails and other data held by U.S. technology companies but stored on servers overseas.

News 12 Staff

Mar 22, 2018, 9:03 PM

Updated 2,310 days ago

Share:

By MARK SHERMAN
Associated Press
WASHINGTON (AP) - The budget bill before Congress includes an update to federal law that makes clear that authorities with a warrant can obtain emails and other data held by American technology companies but stored on servers overseas.
Passage of the Cloud Act probably would end a Supreme Court dispute between Microsoft and the Trump administration over emails the government wants as part of a drug trafficking investigation.
U.S. authorities obtained a warrant for the emails, but Microsoft has refused to provide the emails because they are kept on a Microsoft server in Ireland.
The Cloud Act has the backing of both the administration and Microsoft, but it's opposed by privacy groups. In particular, those groups object to parts of the plan that would regulate how foreign governments could obtain data from U.S. companies.
The House approved the $1.3 trillion budget bill on Thursday and the Senate could vote by week's end. Sen. Rand Paul, R-Ky., has raised questions about the Cloud Act and also opposes the overall spending bill.
Searches of data stored electronically are covered by a 1986 law written long before the advent of cloud computing and the construction of storage centers around the world by the largest technology companies. Earlier proposals to update the law foundered, but the prospect of a Supreme Court ruling increased the urgency to find a measure both sides could agree on.
The administration believes the Cloud Act will give it the data it wants, with a warrant. The companies have worried about regaining the confidence of their international customers following the 2013 leak of classified information detailing America's surveillance programs and the role Microsoft and others played in turning over emails and other information. Microsoft President Brad Smith said in a statement that the Cloud Act "gives tech companies like Microsoft the ability to stand up for the privacy rights of our customers around the world."
The justices themselves seemed eager for Congress to take action when the court heard arguments last month. "Why shouldn't we leave the status quo as it is and let Congress pass a bill in this new age," Justice Sonia Sotomayor asked.
Jennifer Daskal, an American University law professor and former national security official at the Justice Department, said there would be nothing left for the Supreme Court to decide if the Cloud Act becomes law.
The court took up the case to determine whether the 1986 law was intended to cover data controlled by U.S. companies, but held overseas, Daskal said. "The Cloud Act definitely answers that question, saying yes it covers data held overseas," Daskal said in an email.
Copyright 2018 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


More from News 12
1:32
Aunt: Child found dead inside hot car was in the care of a Sullivan County foster family

Aunt: Child found dead inside hot car was in the care of a Sullivan County foster family

1:52
Mainly sunny Friday with seasonable temps in the Hudson Valley

Mainly sunny Friday with seasonable temps in the Hudson Valley

0:33
Orange County man sentenced for hiring hitman to kill neighbor

Orange County man sentenced for hiring hitman to kill neighbor

1:31
Bedford kennel, animal rescue owner charged with animal cruelty

Bedford kennel, animal rescue owner charged with animal cruelty

1:59
Peekamoose Blue Hole:  The Ulster County swimming hole that's too pretty for its own good

Peekamoose Blue Hole: The Ulster County swimming hole that's too pretty for its own good

1:10
What you need to know about lightning, following scary incident in the Hudson Valley

What you need to know about lightning, following scary incident in the Hudson Valley

0:38
Youths injured during ‘riots’ at Goshen juvenile detention center, sources say

Youths injured during ‘riots’ at Goshen juvenile detention center, sources say

1:47
Chappaqua braces for long cleanup after powerful storms

Chappaqua braces for long cleanup after powerful storms

1:13
Headlines: Teen killed in crash only had learner's permit, nursing home assault, threat to blow up social services

Headlines: Teen killed in crash only had learner's permit, nursing home assault, threat to blow up social services

1:21
Over 1,200 Hudson Valley homes without power after storms

Over 1,200 Hudson Valley homes without power after storms

0:20
SPCA seeks help finding those who dumped 3 Collie mixes

SPCA seeks help finding those who dumped 3 Collie mixes

1:50
Live the lake life for a day on Lake Mahopac

Live the lake life for a day on Lake Mahopac

0:47
Pedal Your Way to Fun: New Hudson River boat offers unique social experience

Pedal Your Way to Fun: New Hudson River boat offers unique social experience

Hudson Valley Weather Photos

Hudson Valley Weather Photos

1:48
How often do meteors enter Earth’s atmosphere?

How often do meteors enter Earth’s atmosphere?

0:22
82-year-old man dies after possible drowning at Canopus Lake

82-year-old man dies after possible drowning at Canopus Lake

1:25
Police: Death of 2-year-old left in hot car in Monticello under investigation

Police: Death of 2-year-old left in hot car in Monticello under investigation

1:51
Toddler rescued from hot car in Nanuet parking lot after father accidentally leaves keys inside, according to police

Toddler rescued from hot car in Nanuet parking lot after father accidentally leaves keys inside, according to police

0:20
President Joe Biden tests positive for COVID-19 while campaigning in Las Vegas

President Joe Biden tests positive for COVID-19 while campaigning in Las Vegas

1:39
‘I thought it looked horrible.’ Ardsley residents criticize design of new village logo

‘I thought it looked horrible.’ Ardsley residents criticize design of new village logo