News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Vote 2026: Westchester elections
68°
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Vote 2026: Westchester elections

Seaford church hopes to get stolen items back after Deer Park man arrested

James Vollaro, 58, was arrested on Wednesday after removing the items from Maria Regina Church, according to the Nassau County Police Department.

Mike Smollins

•

Oct 9, 2026, 10:14 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

A Seaford church remains without some of its religious items after a Deer Park man allegedly stole sacramentals from the building.

James Vollaro, 58, was arrested on Wednesday after removing the items from Maria Regina Church, according to the Nassau County Police Department.

The Rev. Jason Grisafi said the stolen items included an altar cross, other crosses and statues, some of which have more than physical value.

"These have a type of religious value to them that goes beyond just a material value," Grisafi said.

Grisafi said the items were used for prayer services and private devotions and that many parishioners pray with them and see it as way of connecting to them spiritually. He said the altar cross meant a great deal to him because he got it while on a Pilgrimage to Jerusalem.

Police said Vollaro was located at his home and arrested after the incident. He was charged with grand larceny and will return to First District Court in Hempstead on Oct. 21.

Grisafi said he was grateful to parishioners for reporting the stolen items. He added that they have not been recovered, but he remains hopeful.

"For those other items that were part of those shrine areas, there's really not much to do to replace them," Grisafi said. "They're kind of irreplaceable. If they're found, great, we'll put them back. If not, new people with new prayers will bring things forward."

Top Stories

CELLPHONE RECORDING OTS copy

Man accused of recording people with hidden phone inside White Plains restaurant bathroom

01:36
Headlines - 3 lines - Evening

Some heavy rain is possible on Friday across the Hudson Valley before we dry out over the weekend

01:05
Screenshot 2026-11-05 165739

Ardsley motorcyclist killed in Valhalla crash, police say

00:25
hit and run arrest

Newburgh man arrested in deadly hit-and-run

00:21
drug bust

Man with crossbow arrested on drug charges in Beacon

01:39
Screenshot 2026-11-05 123823

Vote counting continues in Westchester after widespread machine problems, no estimate on completion

MTWCBallotIssues1104_2026-11-04-17-58-00

LIVE ELECTION UPDATES: Westchester begins counting secured emergency ballots

01:28
Screenshot 2026-11-05 164439

Brewer Fire Engine Company sues Monsey Fire District

02:06
Screenshot 2026-11-05 113647

Road Trip Close To Home: Rock Fantasy mixes rock ’n’ roll, vinyl and about 60 pinball machines under one roof

00:25
Screenshot 2026-11-05 162915

Man accused of stabbing 71-year-old victim 28 times indicted on murder charge in Dutchess County

00:38
Screenshot 2026-11-05 122830

Man admits killing partner while her 2 little girls slept in another room

00:26
Drugs

Passenger allegedly tosses bag with 544 grams of cocaine during Thruway traffic stop

01:37
115juliajetblue_subclip_subclip_2026-11-05-06-13-54_06-02-01,18

JetBlue raises checked bag fees again, citing higher fuel costs amid Iran conflict

Vote 2026

VOTE 2026: Westchester Election Results

01:48
SUNSETPARKFIRE430PZC_2026-11-05-16-48-18

Deadly Sunset Park fire renews calls for action on lithium-ion battery dangers

01:27
Image

Winner, winner, chicken breakfast: New White Plains Chick-fil-A celebrates opening with free food

01:20
Screenshot 2026-11-04 131835

Bradley Whitford celebrates a Broadway homecoming in “A Few Good Men,” the show where it all began

02:07
VsBillyJoelMotorcycles_2026-11-04-17-28-45

A look at Billy Joel’s motorcycle collection as it heads to auction

00:55
BLAISE CRYSTAL RUN

Crystal Run patients raise concerns over doctor departures and possible cuts to specialty services

00:24
Screenshot 2026-11-04 224045

Dutchess County man sentenced for string of burglaries

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices