News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Clear
50°
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics

Seaford church hopes to get stolen items back after Deer Park man arrested

James Vollaro, 58, was arrested on Wednesday after removing the items from Maria Regina Church, according to the Nassau County Police Department.

Mike Smollins

•

Oct 9, 2026, 10:14 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

A Seaford church remains without some of its religious items after a Deer Park man allegedly stole sacramentals from the building.

James Vollaro, 58, was arrested on Wednesday after removing the items from Maria Regina Church, according to the Nassau County Police Department.

The Rev. Jason Grisafi said the stolen items included an altar cross, other crosses and statues, some of which have more than physical value.

"These have a type of religious value to them that goes beyond just a material value," Grisafi said.

Grisafi said the items were used for prayer services and private devotions and that many parishioners pray with them and see it as way of connecting to them spiritually. He said the altar cross meant a great deal to him because he got it while on a Pilgrimage to Jerusalem.

Police said Vollaro was located at his home and arrested after the incident. He was charged with grand larceny and will return to First District Court in Hempstead on Oct. 21.

Grisafi said he was grateful to parishioners for reporting the stolen items. He added that they have not been recovered, but he remains hopeful.

"For those other items that were part of those shrine areas, there's really not much to do to replace them," Grisafi said. "They're kind of irreplaceable. If they're found, great, we'll put them back. If not, new people with new prayers will bring things forward."

Top Stories

01:36
Screenshot 2026-10-09 155355

2 Mount Vernon men charged in separate shoplifting incidents at Cross County Center

01:24
FX Impacts 1

Get out and enjoy beautiful Hudson Valley weather before rain moves in on Sunday

00:39
5c7adfe0-e707-421c-aa74-46e900158ade

AG: Officer who fatally shot sword-wielding man in Poughkeepsie won’t face charges

00:16
Screenshot 2026-10-09 205148

West Haverstraw school opens new track with help from Optimum donation

00:25
Screenshot 2026-10-09 155355

Gov. Hochul asks President Trump to suspend ICE operations in NY

01:46
438ae3a5-8781-4ff0-a161-93bb936262c2

2-weekend pilot program hopes to bring back ferry service between Newburgh and Beacon

01:45
Screenshot 2026-10-09 163307

Officials in Hudson Valley urge awareness as data shows concerning trend in e-bike crashes

01:47
Screenshot 2026-10-09 052432

Students approached by person in white van in separate Scarsdale incidents, patrols increased

00:51
Image

Landscaper killed after runaway truck incident in Blauvelt

00:25
Screenshot 2026-10-09 071235 edited

Denny’s serves up syrup-filled sneakers with return of ‘Sticky Kicks’

01:39
blaise newburgh

Ring video captures screams for help as Newburgh woman says man strangled her in bathroom

00:28
Screenshot 2026-10-09 053341

Step inside Wildcliff Mansion for a night of horror, legend and cinematic scares

01:54
blaise washingtonville

Parents: Washingtonville students forced to interact with teen accused of putting them on what parents call a ‘kill list’

00:13
Screenshot 2026-10-09 053403

Congers Lake Trailway repairs begin; full loop around lake expected by mid-November

01:38
Screenshot 2026-10-08 212106

Water main break sends water rushing down Hollowbrook Lane in Cortlandt

00:17
Screenshot 2026-10-08 212708

Car hangs over retaining wall after Bedford crash

sentencing generic

Former Pleasant Valley official sentenced for secretly filming secretary

02:47
tttnursinghomeabusefoloCM_2026-10-08-17-05-08

'It makes you cringe.' DA demands stronger patient protections after aide's plea deal

00:24
843e8ca3-b88f-4c75-b478-a67f70b6cbb4

Fire damages Sloatsburg home, draws response from 4 fire departments

01:44
Screenshot 2026-10-08 163324

Community weighs in on proposed safety enhancement project for busy Westchester road

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices