News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files

Judge dismisses Rockland election results lawsuit seeking recount of 2024 results

State Supreme Court Judge Rachel Tanguay has dismissed a lawsuit filed by SMART Legislation that was seeking a hand recount in 2024 presidential and U.S. Senate election results in Rockland County.

Diane Caruso

Dec 16, 2025, 5:14 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

State Supreme Court Judge Rachel Tanguay dismissed a lawsuit filed by SMART Legislation that was seeking a hand recount in 2024 presidential and U.S. Senate election results in Rockland County.

Judge Tanguay's decision stated they "lacked standing" and other legal requirements.

In a statement to News 12, Rockland's Board of Elections says they plan to "continue to administer and certify election results in accordance with all applicable laws and procedures.”

"We consider this a victory, even though we didn't get a hand count. We got a tremendous amount of information in discovery," said Lulu Friesdat, with SMART Legislation.

She adds they learned about the way passwords to voting machines are handled, received conflicting information, among other things.

Friesdat says they are glad they brought the lawsuit,

"We want to emphasize the case was not dismissed on its merits," said Friesdat.

One of SMART Legislation's claims involved a third-party candidate for New York's U.S. Senate seat. Rockland resident Diane Sare had sworn affidavits from more voters than what is reflected in the result totals for two districts.

More Stories

Top Stories

01:40
Screenshot 2026-05-11 143123

3 New Yorkers among passengers exposed in MV Hondius hantavirus outbreak, says DOH

01:42
headlines HV

Wall-to-wall sunshine moves in across the Hudson Valley

00:23
0509fallenstatue_2026-05-09-11-11-21

Statue falls and injures man at Somers church

00:23
5122026YORKTOWNSCHOOLARREST_2026-05-12-06-44-47

Private school employee charged after alleged abuse of student with disabilities

00:43
Screenshot 2026-05-12 085022

Kayaking trip turns deadly as Yonkers man is found in upstate New York

02:00
Screenshot 2026-05-12 054353

Scarsdale school board addresses recent antisemitic incident

00:35
A34519B1-B1AE-AC87-B947B25E13E7565A

Pickup truck crashes into stone barrier in Putnam County, driver walks away

Crime Files

Murder in the Hamptons: The Ted Ammon story

00:21
5122025MOREIBMARRESTS2_2026-05-12-05-57-02

3 more teens charged as police continue crack down on break-ins at Somers IBM property

01:43
RTWCHVMamaroneckPublicPotBanJNash5pm_2026-05-11-17-16-13

Proposed law could ban smoking marijuana in public, outdoor places in Village of Mamaroneck

01:23
LIHotToys512_2026-05-12-06-02-21

Hot Toys: Super Mario toys

01:36
WC_5PM_BBgun Found_ajc_2026-05-11-17-07-36

Realistic-looking BB gun prompts lockdown at Irvington schools

01:49
WC 10P MON_Gas Tax Suspenstion_ajc_2026-05-11-22-08-41

Getting a break at the pump? Westchester drivers weigh proposed gas tax holiday

01:58
WC_5PM_GunBust_ajc_2026-05-11-17-08-40

89 guns seized in Liberty from men believed to be trying to smuggle weapons into Canada

02:22
Dems in NY-17

The race for NY-17: Meet the 5 Democrats vying to take on Rep. Mike Lawler

00:23
SEXUAL ABUSE ARREST MONITOR copy

Stamford man accused of sexually abusing 13-year-old in Connecticut and Westchester County

00:33
blaise highland mills drowning

5-year-old found unresponsive in Highland Mills pool flown to hospital in critical condition

01:27
blaise shop shut down

Middletown smoke shop shut down after state says cannabis was sold to 16-year-old

01:43
RTWCHVMamaroneckPublicPotBanJNash5pm_2026-05-11-17-16-13

Proposed law could ban smoking marijuana in public, outdoor places in Village of Mamaroneck

01:41
RTWCHVYonkersGeeseHatchLDValle5pm_2026-05-11-17-24-06

Geese family living at Central Plaza Shopping Center safely accompanied to Crestwood Lake

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices