News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files

Highland Falls officials, residents cry foul over unauthorized rooster

DiSalvo said his staff will likely have to use valuable time and resources, which are funded by the taxpayers, to go through all necessary legal steps to allow village staff to go onto the property to remove the rooster and the hens.

Ben Nandy

Jul 9, 2025, 6:00 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Cindy Phillips cannot take it anymore.

Every morning for the last 11 months, a rooster just a few doors down from her starts crowing - and just keeps going.

"He screams, typically, all day, every day," she said during News 12's visit to her home Wednesday.

Phillips has filed complaints with Village Hall, the police and the Town of Highlands Building Department regarding the rooster, which lives with a few hens in a tight backyard setting.

She also wrote a letter to the editor of The News of The Highlands, which was published in full.

"Last August, it became painfully obvious that the neighbors had a rooster that screams from sun-up to sundown," Phillips read from her letter. "It's unfair for everyone to have to listen to this rooster daily and be exposed to sewage that can endanger our health."

Highland Falls village code limits loud animals that may cause disturbances within a neighborhood.

The code also states livestock shelters cannot be located within 100 feet of any property line.

News 12 reviewed multiple notices of code violations filed by town and village officials against Robert Lerch, a tenant at the Schneider Avenue home.

Mayor James DiSalvo said each time the police and building department officials have tried to serve him with the notices, Lerch would not open the door.

DiSalvo said his staff will likely have to use valuable time and resources, which are funded by the taxpayers, to go through all necessary legal steps to allow village staff to go onto the property to remove the rooster and the hens.

"[He was] notified it was an issue and not allowed, didn't care, don't care that they're bothering their neighbors," DiSalvo said in an interview Wednesday at his office, "so now we're at this point."

A man who answered the door of the residence Wednesday morning said he had nothing to add to the story and did not want to comment.

Phillips came away from her most recent talk with village officials optimistic.

"In the scheme of the world, it doesn't seem like a big deal," she said, "but everyday for 11 months? It's kind of a big deal now."

DiSalvo said Lerch has until August 1 to remove the rooster or else village staff will remove the rooster.

More Stories

Top Stories

02:22
TRUMP

Road closures and traffic expected for President Trump's visit to Rockland County

02:11
weather to watch headlines futurecast HV

Weather To Watch: Rain and wind could impact your Memorial Day weekend plans

00:25
5222026RYEBROOKGRANDLARCENY_2026-05-22-05-36-48

Former NYPD officer admits stealing more than $100,000 from Westchester bank customers

00:18
5222026CROTONBARNFIRE_2026-05-22-05-37-40

Large fire destroys barn in Croton-on-Hudson

01:38
blaise kaplan investigation

Police investigate alleged sexual assault involving nonverbal student at West Nyack school

01:01
fraud charges

3 Yonkers residents among 11 facing federal charges in scheme to evade tolls, traffic tickets

01:14
522026WCdiverse_2026-05-22-08-18-27

Colorful celebration of cultural diversity brings Yonkers students and families together

00:27
5212026DASHCAMTHRUWAYCRASH_2026-05-21-05-44-30

Dashcam video shows fatal Thruway crash involving off-duty NYPD officer from Nanuet

01:54
Screenshot 2026-05-22 062237

From PCOS to PMOS: Why doctors say the new name matters for women’s health

00:28
522toyrecall_2026-05-22-06-24-11

Orb Funkee Squeeze Toys recalled for asbestos risk

00:19
New Rochelle Missing Boy

Renewed search underway for missing 11-year-old taken from New Rochelle last year

00:17
0521briarclifffuneralservices_2026-05-21-16-41-10

Loved ones mourn woman who died in Manhattan manhole fall

01:33
WCWPBARASSAULT0521430P_2026-05-21-16-47-53

Employee assaulted at White Plains business

01:44
0521greenburghcamp_2026-05-21-16-56-34

Greenburgh-based camp fined for not having permit following near-drowning incident last year

01:49
Screenshot 2026-05-21 060603

Strong storms slam Hudson Valley with heavy rain, wind, and hail

01:43
wchvmemdayservice521_2026-05-21-16-58-56

Dutchess County honors veterans, first responders ahead of Memorial Day

01:25
blaise pj dog abuse

Port Jervis man charged after videos appear to show dog abuse

01:42
wchvemsprogram521_2026-05-21-16-59-34

Phelps Hospital launches street medicine program to bring care to the homeless

01:47
0520armonkassaultsentencing_2026-05-20-16-41-54

Armonk man sentenced to 11 years in state prison for attempted assault of police officer

01:48
YONKERSSCHOOLCLOSUREPKG0520430P_2026-05-20-16-51-54

Growing concern as Yonkers school board considers shutting down School 21

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices