Libel suit against ex-anonymous Rockland blogger raises 1st Amendment concerns

<p>A libel lawsuit against a formerly anonymous Rockland blogger is now raising some First Amendment concerns after the writer's identity was outed in court and the case kept sealed.</p>

News 12 Staff

Dec 11, 2018, 10:08 PM

Updated 1,961 days ago

Share:

A libel lawsuit against a formerly anonymous Rockland blogger is now raising some First Amendment concerns after the writer's identity was outed in court and the case kept sealed.
For two years, Rockland corporate fraud attorney Julie Globus has been writing anonymously about alleged crimes and misdeeds in the Rockland Hasidic community under the blog name "Lost Messiah."
"I have this weird ability to connect dots and find dots," she says.
Earlier this year, those "dots" led Globus to the state Supreme Court in a libel lawsuit that outed her identity, filed by Brooklyn based real-estate titans Louis and Joel Kestenbaum, for two articles she wrote about them in 2016.
"There were underlying lawsuits that were cited and there was an underlying article that was cited, all of which, at the time, I viewed as credible,” said Globus.
Globus' attorney calls the case a "triple assault" on the First Amendment, with the "unmasking" of her identity, the alleged failure to prove malicious intent and the court’s sealing of the case.
That last part in particular garnered the attention of UCLA law professor and Washington Post columnist Eugene Volokh.
"In American law, litigation is supposed to be out in the open so the public can monitor what's going on,” says Volokh.
According to statements made by Kestenbaum's attorney, unsealing the case would "re-victimize" his clients.
Volokh disagrees, saying, “Secrecy is seen as even more dangerous because it increases the risk that the judicial process won't go the right way."
A Supreme Court judge is currently reviewing arguments about whether or not to unseal the case.
The attorney for Louis and Joel Kestenbaum declined to comment for News 12’s story      


More from News 12
1:51
Traffic delays and road closures expected as Irvington set to host President Joe Biden today

Traffic delays and road closures expected as Irvington set to host President Joe Biden today

2:20
Sunny and pleasant today, freeze warnings overnight

Sunny and pleasant today, freeze warnings overnight

1:41
Pro-Palestinian protest expected in Irvington during President Biden's visit to Westchester

Pro-Palestinian protest expected in Irvington during President Biden's visit to Westchester

1:57
Schools in Westchester County announce early dismissals ahead of President Biden's visit

Schools in Westchester County announce early dismissals ahead of President Biden's visit

1:53
Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

0:25
Dramatic video captures car fire in Nanuet

Dramatic video captures car fire in Nanuet

Vote 2024: Ask your questions for Congressional District 16 Democratic candidates

Vote 2024: Ask your questions for Congressional District 16 Democratic candidates

0:24
New York appeals court overturns Harvey Weinstein’s 2020 rape conviction from landmark #MeToo trial

New York appeals court overturns Harvey Weinstein’s 2020 rape conviction from landmark #MeToo trial

0:24
Breeze Airways expands services from Westchester County Airport

Breeze Airways expands services from Westchester County Airport

1:47
Saddle up for a western-style riding adventure at Hollow Brook Riding Academy!

Saddle up for a western-style riding adventure at Hollow Brook Riding Academy!

0:27
Oklahoma woman pleads guilty in fatal Newburgh drunk driving crash

Oklahoma woman pleads guilty in fatal Newburgh drunk driving crash

0:45
Yonkers officer faces charges in off-duty Bronxville accident

Yonkers officer faces charges in off-duty Bronxville accident

0:21
Dutchess County drivers awarded free cars after completing empowerment program

Dutchess County drivers awarded free cars after completing empowerment program

0:35
20 Hudson Valley public high schools among top 100 in New York state

20 Hudson Valley public high schools among top 100 in New York state

1:09
Headlines: Burglary guilty plea, illegal AR-15 possession, library larceny

Headlines: Burglary guilty plea, illegal AR-15 possession, library larceny

0:17
St. Barnabas High School marks 100 years of education at New Rochelle gala

St. Barnabas High School marks 100 years of education at New Rochelle gala

0:27
Manhattan College and Rockland Community College partnership allows seamless student transfers

Manhattan College and Rockland Community College partnership allows seamless student transfers

0:25
Orangeburg students crowned winners of entrepreneurship competition

Orangeburg students crowned winners of entrepreneurship competition

0:26
Luxury VIP experience coming to Woodbury Common Premium Outlets

Luxury VIP experience coming to Woodbury Common Premium Outlets

2:27
How to protect spring plants from frost and freeze

How to protect spring plants from frost and freeze