Secular education in yeshivas debate turns contentious in Rockland

There was name-calling and finger-pointing outside the Rockland County Courthouse Friday over whether the state should enforce a law requiring private schools like yeshivas to teach some secular subjects.

News 12 Staff

Aug 23, 2019, 9:29 PM

Updated 1,719 days ago

Share:

There was name-calling and finger-pointing outside the Rockland County Courthouse Friday over whether the state should enforce a law requiring private schools like yeshivas to teach some secular subjects.
Both sides of the debate showed up at an event with local lawmakers held by YAFFED, or Young Advocates for Fair Education.
The nonprofit is urging people to support the state's proposed regulations that would enforce curriculum standards in yeshivas, Catholic schools and other non-public educational institutions.
“The fact that we have tens of thousands of children not getting an education is a serious problem,” says Naftuli Moster, of the Young Advocates group. “But it's also a human rights violation because these children grow up totally ill-prepared for the workforce. They can't pursue a higher education.”
Advocates say high school boys at yeshivas get no secular education at all while middle school and elementary school boys receive 90 minutes of secular learning four days a week.
Not everyone agrees with those statistics, including Legislator Aron Wieder, who said “Moster is perpetuation the biggest lie in the state of New York.”
Parents of yeshiva students told News 12 that they are worried their children aren't getting an education that will prepare them for work – let alone life outside the Hasidim.
Public comment for the proposed regulation end on Sept. 2.


More from News 12
1:46
 21-year-old SUNY Purchase art student overcomes childhood trauma through music

21-year-old SUNY Purchase art student overcomes childhood trauma through music

1:15
Police: Man pulled from Ossining house fire dies at hospital

Police: Man pulled from Ossining house fire dies at hospital

2:26
STORM WATCH: Showers, isolated thunderstorms during Wednesday morning commute

STORM WATCH: Showers, isolated thunderstorms during Wednesday morning commute

1:08
Hospital workers picket over Westchester Medical Center Health Network layoffs

Hospital workers picket over Westchester Medical Center Health Network layoffs

0:57
5 puppies rescued from sealed shipping container on I-84 in Bedford

5 puppies rescued from sealed shipping container on I-84 in Bedford

1:42
Poughkeepsie council weighs opting into rent stabilization under Emergency Tenant Protection Act

Poughkeepsie council weighs opting into rent stabilization under Emergency Tenant Protection Act

1:58
Officials mull traffic safety projects following 5th child struck by car in 5 months in Rockland neighborhood

Officials mull traffic safety projects following 5th child struck by car in 5 months in Rockland neighborhood

0:36
Reports: Body of missing Army National Guard sergeant found

Reports: Body of missing Army National Guard sergeant found

0:25
Pine Bush man pleads guilty to aggravated vehicular assault that left teen paralyzed

Pine Bush man pleads guilty to aggravated vehicular assault that left teen paralyzed

0:39
Westchester County Health Department to inspect 235 children’s camps ahead of summer

Westchester County Health Department to inspect 235 children’s camps ahead of summer

0:24
Mount Vernon launches new grant program for small businesses

Mount Vernon launches new grant program for small businesses

0:39
 ‘Melanie’s Law’ passes state Senate, heads for final approval

‘Melanie’s Law’ passes state Senate, heads for final approval

0:29
Attorney General James sues local clinics for abortion-reversal claims

Attorney General James sues local clinics for abortion-reversal claims

0:20
East Ramapo parents rally for school reform

East Ramapo parents rally for school reform

1:56
Ceremony held to mark Holocaust Remembrance Day in White Plains

Ceremony held to mark Holocaust Remembrance Day in White Plains

1:42
24-year-old double organ transplant recipient hosts blood drive in Pomona

24-year-old double organ transplant recipient hosts blood drive in Pomona

1:49
SUNY Purchase faculty and students want disciplinary action against protesters dropped

SUNY Purchase faculty and students want disciplinary action against protesters dropped

0:50
Orange County cracks down on drivers who illegally pass school buses with cameras

Orange County cracks down on drivers who illegally pass school buses with cameras

1:36
‘Very best’ of PD: City of Newburgh promotes longtime lieutenant to chief

‘Very best’ of PD: City of Newburgh promotes longtime lieutenant to chief

0:23
State police work to ID body that washed ashore in Poughkeepsie

State police work to ID body that washed ashore in Poughkeepsie