Putnam DA pushes for moratorium on Discovery Law

Putnam County District Attorney Robert Tendy says his workload has increased exponentially since the reform of New York State's Discovery Law took effect Jan. 1.

News 12 Staff

Jan 15, 2020, 1:35 AM

Updated 1,568 days ago

Share:

Putnam County District Attorney Robert Tendy says his workload has increased exponentially since the reform of New York State's Discovery Law took effect Jan. 1.
District Attorney Tendy is sounding off on reform legislation that requires law enforcement agencies to give every piece of evidence to defense teams within 15 days of their arraignment. Tendy fears what could happen when agencies start missing deadlines.
"There's going to be evidence that's going to be suppressed, cases may be dismissed...And those smaller cases are going to suffer. Anybody in this business knows, when small crime blows up, big crime happens," he says.
Tendy says that Putnam County has been obligated to release at least three jailed suspects under the new law.
The suspects qualified for release because their charges were considered non-violent. One of the suspects was arrested for leaving the scene of a fatal accident.
Tendy is pushing for a moratorium on the law.
Many agencies worry about overtime costs because of the extra clerical work required, but in a News 12 exclusive, Lt. Gov. Kathy Hochul insists agencies are saving money now.
"By not having so many people incarcerated, the counties will see costs reduced dramatically but... non-violent offense," she says.
Richard Willstatter, a criminal defense lawyer, says the new law needs time to play out because it evens the playing field.
"The new law will provide information to the defense so that defendants will be able to make a reasonable decision with what to do with their case. Either plead guilty or go to trial and will make the system, in fact, more just and more efficient," says Willstatter.
Tendy says he is hopeful that lawmakers will realize that the law needs some change.
 


More from News 12
1:48
Newburgh charity founder faces federal charges, accused of falsely claiming to be a Purple Heart recipient and stealing from the VA

Newburgh charity founder faces federal charges, accused of falsely claiming to be a Purple Heart recipient and stealing from the VA

2:12
Summer feeling with highs in the 80s tomorrow in the Hudson Valley

Summer feeling with highs in the 80s tomorrow in the Hudson Valley

0:53
Health care workers picket outside Phelps Hospital demanding better conditions

Health care workers picket outside Phelps Hospital demanding better conditions

0:41
Sen. Gillibrand announces passage of new bill to fight fentanyl crisis

Sen. Gillibrand announces passage of new bill to fight fentanyl crisis

0:50
Westchester county executive announces $3 million allocated to build affordable housing in Mamaroneck

Westchester county executive announces $3 million allocated to build affordable housing in Mamaroneck

0:33
Changes to recreational striped bass fishing regulations in the Hudson River

Changes to recreational striped bass fishing regulations in the Hudson River

0:39
DEC: Bloomingburg taking ‘corrective action’ to fix major sewage leak into Shawangunk Kill

DEC: Bloomingburg taking ‘corrective action’ to fix major sewage leak into Shawangunk Kill

0:32
Suspect arrested in fatal shooting at unlicensed cannabis store in Mount Vernon

Suspect arrested in fatal shooting at unlicensed cannabis store in Mount Vernon

0:20
Arrest made in Spring Valley stabbing case

Arrest made in Spring Valley stabbing case

0:31
Putnam County man killed in crash following pursuit

Putnam County man killed in crash following pursuit

0:51
Westchester County allocates $3 million for affordable housing in Mamaroneck

Westchester County allocates $3 million for affordable housing in Mamaroneck

2:07
Traffic Alert: Speed limit reduced to 25 mph in White Plains

Traffic Alert: Speed limit reduced to 25 mph in White Plains

0:35
Westchester County issues warning regarding phony contractors

Westchester County issues warning regarding phony contractors

0:35
Traffic Alert: Postponed construction on Orrs Mill Road in Town of Cornwall

Traffic Alert: Postponed construction on Orrs Mill Road in Town of Cornwall

1:53
Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

0:33
What marijuana reclassification means for the United States

What marijuana reclassification means for the United States

0:56
Homeless man arrested for 20th time in Ulster County for possessing stolen items

Homeless man arrested for 20th time in Ulster County for possessing stolen items

0:25
Attention Cold Spring residents: Fireworks alert

Attention Cold Spring residents: Fireworks alert

0:25
Meet the therapy dogs bringing joy to White Plains Hospital

Meet the therapy dogs bringing joy to White Plains Hospital

1:12
Headlines: Beacon drug dealer arrested again, Haverstraw burglary, prison health care fraudsters

Headlines: Beacon drug dealer arrested again, Haverstraw burglary, prison health care fraudsters