Painting valued at nearly $30K mistakenly sold for $200 at Thornwood tag sale

A 25-by-30-inch oil painting called “Country Fair” was mistakenly sold at a tag sale in Thornwood last month.

News 12 Staff

Nov 13, 2019, 10:40 PM

Updated 1,633 days ago

Share:

A 25-by-30-inch oil painting called “Country Fair” was mistakenly sold at a tag sale in Thornwood last month.
Helen Giustino, 88, says she acquired the painting with her late husband from a flea market over 30 years ago.
“It was something my husband loved. It was a flea market, he loved flea markets, that was part of our entertainment through our years,” says Giustino.
The widow’s son sold the piece for a mere $200. Turns out it is valued at nearly $30,000. She says she is angry and emotional to know that the piece is gone.
The painting, which was featured in a 1947 Maxwell House ad, was scheduled to be auctioned off at the end of November.
Ronnan Clarke, owner of Clarke's Auction Gallery in Larchmont, intended to keep 10% of the sale and give the consignor, Dr. Sidney Hiller of Briarcliff, the rest.
Hiller says he plans to take the painting back from the auction house and pursue ownership. He declined to comment on whether he would return it to the original owner.
Giustino’s attorney, John Murtagh, says the family is prepared to take legal action.
“The right, ethical, equitable things to do would be let's everybody go back to square one, give Helen back the painting that means so much to her, we can give him back the $200 he paid for it and this is over and done,” says Murtagh.


More from News 12
1:56
SUNY Purchase administrators monitor campus following encampment arrests

SUNY Purchase administrators monitor campus following encampment arrests

0:52
Jewish students at SUNY New Paltz share experience on campus as protests continue to unfold

Jewish students at SUNY New Paltz share experience on campus as protests continue to unfold

1:56
Afternoon showers for Saturday in the Hudson Valley; batches of light rain for Sunday

Afternoon showers for Saturday in the Hudson Valley; batches of light rain for Sunday

0:43
Westchester County police officer dies in accident at home

Westchester County police officer dies in accident at home

0:53
New Town Supervisor Ed Lachterman inaugurated at Yorktown Town Hall

New Town Supervisor Ed Lachterman inaugurated at Yorktown Town Hall

0:28
Tarrytown Catholic school to close permanently

Tarrytown Catholic school to close permanently

0:21
$39 flights connect Westchester County and Raleigh-Durham

$39 flights connect Westchester County and Raleigh-Durham

0:36
Animated 'X-Men' TV series superhero mansion brought to life in Westchester County

Animated 'X-Men' TV series superhero mansion brought to life in Westchester County

2:07
SUNY Purchase students 'scared to go outside' after college police raid encampment

SUNY Purchase students 'scared to go outside' after college police raid encampment

1:39
Police: 133 arrested during growing pro-Palestinian demonstration on SUNY New Paltz campus

Police: 133 arrested during growing pro-Palestinian demonstration on SUNY New Paltz campus

0:46
Driver crashes into Yonkers dry cleaning business

Driver crashes into Yonkers dry cleaning business

0:20
Police corral horse on the loose in New Rochelle

Police corral horse on the loose in New Rochelle

0:47
State officials: $11M in funding allocated for flood mitigation projects in Mamaroneck

State officials: $11M in funding allocated for flood mitigation projects in Mamaroneck

0:58
Report: More people going hungry in NY despite economic growth

Report: More people going hungry in NY despite economic growth

0:27
Westchester's NCADD honors News 12's Jonathan Gordon with 'humanitarian award'

Westchester's NCADD honors News 12's Jonathan Gordon with 'humanitarian award'

1:01
Monticello police sergeant alleges retaliation for working with prosecutors to arrest ex-officer

Monticello police sergeant alleges retaliation for working with prosecutors to arrest ex-officer

3:21
Bridge over section of I-95 in process of being demolished due to damage from truck fire

Bridge over section of I-95 in process of being demolished due to damage from truck fire

0:41
Police: Child sustained minor injuries when struck by on-duty Monticello police officer

Police: Child sustained minor injuries when struck by on-duty Monticello police officer

1:26
Look up! Annual Eta Aquarid meteor shower peaks early Sunday morning

Look up! Annual Eta Aquarid meteor shower peaks early Sunday morning

0:23
Overnight road work to close Exit 7 on Cross County Parkway in Westchester

Overnight road work to close Exit 7 on Cross County Parkway in Westchester