Menendez Trial: Juror asks for definition of 'senator'

<p>The jury in the bribery trial of Sen. Bob Menendez Jurors resumed deliberations Wednesday following one juror's&nbsp;head-scratching question.</p>

News 12 Staff

Nov 7, 2017, 11:13 AM

Updated 2,368 days ago

Share:

By DAVID PORTER
Associated Press
NEWARK, N.J. (AP) -- Jurors resumed Wednesday for day three of deliberations in the bribery trial of Sen. Bob Menendez.
The jury its first full day of deliberations Tuesday without a verdict, but not before asking a question that had some in the courtroom scratching their heads.
A juror asked the judge Tuesday to read back part of Monday's closing argument by the New Jersey Democrat's lawyer that dealt with the definition of a senator.
The judge declined, saying only testimony can be read back and closing arguments aren't testimony.
Menendez is charged with accepting gifts such as flights on a private jet and luxury vacations from Florida eye doctor Salomon Melgen in exchange for political influence.
An indictment alleges Menendez pushed executive branch officials to resolve Melgen's $8.9 million Medicare billing dispute and his stalled port security contract in the Dominican Republic.
The juror's question could have been referring to the fact Melgen isn't a New Jersey resident. Prosecutors have argued since he wasn't a constituent of Menendez's, that showed Menendez was influenced by the alleged bribes.
Defense attorneys have argued Menendez routinely helped people based on issues and not geography, and pointed to his involvement in Hispanic issues nationally.
Menendez defense attorney Abbe Lowell also mentioned in his closing Monday that Menendez didn't propose any legislation aimed at helping Melgen's business interests, and didn't have the authority to force the officials he approached to act on Melgen's behalf.
The case could have implications for a deeply divided Senate if Menendez is convicted and he steps down or is voted out by a two-thirds majority, though neither scenario is considered likely. If either came to pass before New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie leaves office Jan. 16, the term-limited Republican governor could appoint a replacement.
Menendez is up for re-election next year.
A 2016 Supreme Court ruling that overturned the bribery conviction of former Republican Virginia Gov. Bob McDonnell will loom over jury deliberations. The ruling created a narrower definition of what are considered "official acts" in a bribery scheme, and U.S. District Judge William Walls used language directly from the court's ruling in his instructions to the Menendez jurors.
Defense attorneys focused part of their closing arguments on the requirement that the official - Menendez - has to agree to perform an official act "at the time of the agreement" to be found guilty, and told jurors the prosecution didn't present any evidence of an actual agreement between Menendez and Melgen.
Prosecutors argued to jurors that Menendez's meetings with officials in the departments of State, Commerce and Health and Human Services constituted official acts that were meant to benefit Melgen specifically.
Menendez's attorneys have argued the meetings focused on broader policy issues.
Menendez, the son of Cuban immigrants, served in the U.S. House from 1993 until filling the Senate seat vacated when Democrat Jon Corzine became New Jersey governor in 2006.
Copyright 2017 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


More from News 12
1:47
Ex-Monticello officer who admitted to raping underage teen reinstated to department after arrest

Ex-Monticello officer who admitted to raping underage teen reinstated to department after arrest

2:08
Partly sunny, light breeze for Friday in the Hudson Valley; afternoon showers for Saturday

Partly sunny, light breeze for Friday in the Hudson Valley; afternoon showers for Saturday

0:36
Police: Woman arrested in connection to student brawl outside Yonkers school

Police: Woman arrested in connection to student brawl outside Yonkers school

1:44
Poughkeepsie leaders ask public for help to find troubled teens before tragedy strikes

Poughkeepsie leaders ask public for help to find troubled teens before tragedy strikes

1:02
Ribbon-cutting ceremony held for completion of New Rochelle affordable housing development

Ribbon-cutting ceremony held for completion of New Rochelle affordable housing development

0:32
Bedford School District to receive more money aid, boost in funding from state

Bedford School District to receive more money aid, boost in funding from state

0:30
Blooming Grove highway worker seriously injured during tree removal

Blooming Grove highway worker seriously injured during tree removal

0:46
New Rochelle business owner pleads guilty to wage violations

New Rochelle business owner pleads guilty to wage violations

0:23
Overnight road work to close Exit 7 on Cross County Parkway in Westchester

Overnight road work to close Exit 7 on Cross County Parkway in Westchester

2:17
Home Depot ban on solicitation impacts day laborers in New Rochelle

Home Depot ban on solicitation impacts day laborers in New Rochelle

2:22
I-95 in Norwalk closed until at least Monday following tractor-trailer fire

I-95 in Norwalk closed until at least Monday following tractor-trailer fire

0:55
Headlines: Child pornography charges, drug dealing guilty plea, cocaine possession sentencing

Headlines: Child pornography charges, drug dealing guilty plea, cocaine possession sentencing

0:33
Woman faces charges for selling weight loss drugs on TikTok without license

Woman faces charges for selling weight loss drugs on TikTok without license

0:28
SPCA Westchester launches first mobile adoption unit

SPCA Westchester launches first mobile adoption unit

0:19
Cross County Center launches 70th anniversary celebration with expanded summer fest

Cross County Center launches 70th anniversary celebration with expanded summer fest

0:26
Rockland residents honor fallen heroes in national weeklong event

Rockland residents honor fallen heroes in national weeklong event

News 12 Westchester/Hudson Valley Daily Poll

News 12 Westchester/Hudson Valley Daily Poll

1:44
Exploring the Westchester children's museum: A journey of play and discovery

Exploring the Westchester children's museum: A journey of play and discovery

0:36
Live Nation Concert Week offers $25 tickets to over 5,000 shows

Live Nation Concert Week offers $25 tickets to over 5,000 shows

1:22
Pro-Palestinian protests make their way to SUNY New Paltz campus

Pro-Palestinian protests make their way to SUNY New Paltz campus