Prosecutors: 5 suspects plotted to kidnap, kill teen to advance MS-13 status

<p>Five suspects with alleged MS-13 gang ties were arraigned in Central Islip court on charges that they tried to kidnap and kill a 16-year-old boy in Brentwood.&nbsp;</p>

News 12 Staff

Dec 20, 2017, 10:35 AM

Updated 2,336 days ago

Share:

Five suspects with alleged MS-13 gang ties were arraigned Wednesday on a grand jury indictment accusing them of trying to kidnap and kill a 16-year-old boy in Brentwood. 
Prosecutors say the attempt earlier this month to kidnap the teen was an attempt to elevate their status within MS-13. 
Prosecutors say Miguel Rivera, Oscar Fuentes, Lilliana Villanueva, Vidal Contrera-Ortiz and Jorge Bermudez had knives, bats, a tarp and duct tape in a van as they attempted to abduct the teenager near First Street and Third Avenue. 
According to court documents, Miguel Rivera told the others that the would-be victim was a rival in the 18th Street Gang. He allegedly said, "We're going to take him somewhere private and beat him to death with the bats." He then identified himself as a member of "MS-13 Carleton Click."
Attorneys for two of the five suspects say their clients are not in MS-13 and that there was no such conspiracy. 
"Just because someone is from El Salvador does not mean automatically that he is a member of MS-13," said Peter Mayer, who is representing Oscar Fuentes. "These are young men who were caught in the wrong place at the wrong time."
Four of the five defendants are Brentwood High School students with no prior criminal history. They were each held on ICE detainers. Officials say they were either in the U.S. illegally or are unaccompanied minors.


More from News 12
0:35
Police officer seriously injured in hit-and-run crash in Dutchess County

Police officer seriously injured in hit-and-run crash in Dutchess County

2:52
Mix of sun and clouds today, steadier rain chances later this week

Mix of sun and clouds today, steadier rain chances later this week

2:26
Latimer and Bowman square off in News 12 debate for Democratic nod in 16th Congressional District

Latimer and Bowman square off in News 12 debate for Democratic nod in 16th Congressional District

NYC man fled traffic stop, crashed on Saw Mill River Parkway; faces slew of charges

NYC man fled traffic stop, crashed on Saw Mill River Parkway; faces slew of charges

Attempted murder suspect charged in violent Poughkeepsie attack released on $1,350 bail

Attempted murder suspect charged in violent Poughkeepsie attack released on $1,350 bail

0:20
Traffic Alert: Road work in Village of Cornwall-on-Hudson

Traffic Alert: Road work in Village of Cornwall-on-Hudson

1:35
MTA makes 50,000 MetroCards featuring Bronx rapper Ice Spice

MTA makes 50,000 MetroCards featuring Bronx rapper Ice Spice

Principal: 2 middle school students attacked by ‘group of adults’ in Newburgh

Principal: 2 middle school students attacked by ‘group of adults’ in Newburgh

0:59
Headlines: Saw Mill Parkway pursuit, off-road vehicle death, missing girl

Headlines: Saw Mill Parkway pursuit, off-road vehicle death, missing girl

2:32
‘You hurt a family.’ Kane In Your Corner reveals animal rescue concerns about Pixies and Paws

‘You hurt a family.’ Kane In Your Corner reveals animal rescue concerns about Pixies and Paws

0:22
New Rochelle man arrested for assaulting two men with baseball bat

New Rochelle man arrested for assaulting two men with baseball bat

1:52
Music legend Paul McCartney responds to viral video of Brooklyn Beatles fan

Music legend Paul McCartney responds to viral video of Brooklyn Beatles fan

0:22
Blossoming community sensory garden in Highland Falls reconnects residents

Blossoming community sensory garden in Highland Falls reconnects residents

0:23
Apple Cinemas set to open new theater complex in downtown White Plains

Apple Cinemas set to open new theater complex in downtown White Plains

0:28
Westchester's beer festival season begins with Suds on the Sound

Westchester's beer festival season begins with Suds on the Sound

0:34
Police: 1 person killed following accident that left vehicle overturned in Mongomery

Police: 1 person killed following accident that left vehicle overturned in Mongomery

0:36
Spending time outdoors? Here are 20 tips to prevent tick bites.

Spending time outdoors? Here are 20 tips to prevent tick bites.

1:31
Police: 75-year-old pedestrian struck by truck, seriously injured in Yonkers

Police: 75-year-old pedestrian struck by truck, seriously injured in Yonkers

2:23
Gabrielle’s Wings: Nonprofit has flourished in the 7 years since New Rochelle girl’s murder

Gabrielle’s Wings: Nonprofit has flourished in the 7 years since New Rochelle girl’s murder

0:30
Haliburton, Pacers take advantage of short-handed Knicks to even series with 121-89 rout in Game 4

Haliburton, Pacers take advantage of short-handed Knicks to even series with 121-89 rout in Game 4