Latest Suffolk deer culling hits legal snag

Federal authorities say an overabundance of white-tailed deer is endangering the forest of a history Suffolk County property, but their plan for a deer cull is being blocked.

News 12 Staff

Feb 20, 2019, 10:53 PM

Updated 1,884 days ago

Share:

Latest Suffolk deer culling hits legal snag
Federal authorities say an overabundance of white-tailed deer is endangering the forest of a history Suffolk County property, but their plan for a deer cull is being blocked.
People living or working near the William Floyd Estate in Mastic Beach might soon hear the sound of gunshots. Federal employees with the National Park Service and other agencies are supposed to start thinning the deer population, killing more than 100 deer that live on the property. Experts say the deer are devastating the landscape and endangering other wildlife.
"Without intervention, this level of deer threaten[s] the forests' ability to sustain itself over the long term," says Elizabeth Rogers, of the National Park Service.
The plan isn't sitting well with Robert Oliver, who lives right next door.
"I came from the Bronx. I grew up in an apartment building as a kid," Oliver says. "I don't want to kill animals. That's why I'm in the country."
The operation is part of a larger plan to decrease the number of deer on Fire Island, but that isn't scheduled to start until next year. There is also the possibility of a public recreational hunt within the Fire Island wilderness area, but that is only an option as of right now.
Jim Hunter, of the Evelyn Alexander Wildlife Rescue Center in Hampton Bays, says he opposes any plan that requires people to kill animals.
"They have a right to survive the same as we have a right to survive," Hunter says. "And I don't think humans should make that decision."
The hunt was scheduled to begin Wednesday, but three out-of-state animal rights groups filed lawsuits. On Tuesday, a federal judge granted one of the groups a temporary restraining order. A hearing is now scheduled for Thursday.
The William Floyd Estate is currently closed for the winter.


More from News 12
0:36
Report of student with gun prompts hold in place at Northern Westchester BOCES campus

Report of student with gun prompts hold in place at Northern Westchester BOCES campus

2:04
Dry afternoon for Friday throughout the Hudson Valley before evening showers roll in

Dry afternoon for Friday throughout the Hudson Valley before evening showers roll in

1:46
Stepfather of man charged in fatal Mount Vernon shooting indicted for murder

Stepfather of man charged in fatal Mount Vernon shooting indicted for murder

Kerhonkson man indicted for killing, dismembering girlfriend

Kerhonkson man indicted for killing, dismembering girlfriend

0:29
Middletown fairgrounds to host Burnout Nationals finale

Middletown fairgrounds to host Burnout Nationals finale

2:06
Lyndhurst in Bloom flower show is this weekend at Lyndhurst Mansion

Lyndhurst in Bloom flower show is this weekend at Lyndhurst Mansion

0:31
Greenwood Lake mayor, village building inspector suddenly resign

Greenwood Lake mayor, village building inspector suddenly resign

Vote 2024: Ask your questions for Congressional District 16 Democratic candidates

Vote 2024: Ask your questions for Congressional District 16 Democratic candidates

1:10
State police in the Hudson Valley ramp up patrols to catch impaired drivers on April 20

State police in the Hudson Valley ramp up patrols to catch impaired drivers on April 20

0:54
Protesters march outside Yonkers County Family Court to call for reform in the system

Protesters march outside Yonkers County Family Court to call for reform in the system

0:38
1 of 2 men charged in Bedford firebombing pleads guilty

1 of 2 men charged in Bedford firebombing pleads guilty

0:24
Holtec International sues NYS over law banning discharge of radiological waste into the Hudson

Holtec International sues NYS over law banning discharge of radiological waste into the Hudson

0:29
Cortlandt community composting program accepting food scraps

Cortlandt community composting program accepting food scraps

0:26
Rifton USPS in Ulster County closed indefinitely due to safety hazard

Rifton USPS in Ulster County closed indefinitely due to safety hazard

0:21
The Orange County Land Trust launches wilderness campaign effort

The Orange County Land Trust launches wilderness campaign effort

0:46
Westchester County’s Environmental Facilities hosted its 5th annual Eco Awards

Westchester County’s Environmental Facilities hosted its 5th annual Eco Awards

0:50
Bark Air is launching flights catered to dogs out of Westchester County Airport

Bark Air is launching flights catered to dogs out of Westchester County Airport

0:40
TEDx Talk at Mamaroneck HS focuses on mental health of adolescents, families, communities

TEDx Talk at Mamaroneck HS focuses on mental health of adolescents, families, communities

Is your mom awesome? Hudson Valley tell us why your Mom Rocks!

Is your mom awesome? Hudson Valley tell us why your Mom Rocks!

0:54
Guide: How to host Passover on a budget

Guide: How to host Passover on a budget