Better Business Bureau warns ‘mystery shopper’ scam on the rise

A Morris County man is out more than $7,000 as the result of a scam that targets people who are already out of work, and the Better Business Bureau says the scam is on the rise in this area.

News 12 Staff

May 16, 2019, 11:41 PM

Updated 1,799 days ago

Share:

A Morris County man is out more than $7,000 as the result of a scam that targets people who are already out of work, and the Better Business Bureau tells Kane In Your Corner the scam is on the rise in this area.
“I’ve got to say, hook line and sinker, I was there,” says Steven Gogerty, who applied online for a job as a “mystery shopper.” His so-called employer told him he was hired and sent him three cashier’s checks, each for about $2,000. Gogerty was told to keep $200 from each one as compensation and use the rest to buy gift cards at various stores.
“I was basically just buying the gift cards and observing the service,” he says.
For days, he drove to store after store, buying the cards, then scratching off the numbers and texting them to the person he thought was his supervisor, so his “employer” could recoup its investment. He even painstakingly wrote numerous reports on the customer service. It wasn’t until about a week later that Gogerty’s bank informed him the cashier’s checks he’d deposited were forged and his account was overdrawn.
“I feel like I’ve been hoodwinked,” he says. “Just conned. It was a good con, I’ll give them that much.”
Melissa Companick of the Better Business Bureau says work-from-home scams are once again on the rise.
“We hear this pretty much every day through our BBB Scam Tracker,” she says. “And I think these are among the saddest because these are people who legitimately need work, who need money, who are looking for opportunities.”
Kane In Your Corner advises people looking for work to beware of red flags. In Gogerty’s case, it was the sheer volume of gift cards he was being asked to buy. A true “mystery shopper” could observe customer service and buy a $10 gift card or an inexpensive piece of merchandise; there would be no reason to buy hundreds of dollars of gift cards at a time.
The compensation might have also been a clue: $200 for assignments that would only take a couple of hours.
“If we all could make that kind of money, everybody would be working from home,” Companick says.


More from News 12
1:22
Preliminary report uncovers over 100 potential unmarked burials at historic Rye cemetery

Preliminary report uncovers over 100 potential unmarked burials at historic Rye cemetery

2:01
Scattered showers for Friday throughout the Hudson Valley before dry, breezy Saturday

Scattered showers for Friday throughout the Hudson Valley before dry, breezy Saturday

0:45
Authorities: Mahopac man captured sexually explicit images of children with hidden camera

Authorities: Mahopac man captured sexually explicit images of children with hidden camera

0:30
Hearing for New City stabbing suspect rescheduled for next week

Hearing for New City stabbing suspect rescheduled for next week

0:53
Carmel School District closes in on budget agreement following months of debates

Carmel School District closes in on budget agreement following months of debates

0:44
Greenburgh's ex-Parks and Recreation commissioner honored with renaming of multipurpose center

Greenburgh's ex-Parks and Recreation commissioner honored with renaming of multipurpose center

0:37
Virginia man was sentenced to 20 years to life in fatal 2021 shooting of New Rochelle cab driver

Virginia man was sentenced to 20 years to life in fatal 2021 shooting of New Rochelle cab driver

0:34
Westchester DA: Yonkers man sentenced 1 1/3 to 4 years in prison for fatal June 2023 hit-and-run

Westchester DA: Yonkers man sentenced 1 1/3 to 4 years in prison for fatal June 2023 hit-and-run

0:28
White Plains police: Teenager arrested in connection to stabbing of 17-year-old outside gas station

White Plains police: Teenager arrested in connection to stabbing of 17-year-old outside gas station

1:54
Middletown couple fight through lawsuits, zoning problems to open New Paltz cannabis dispensary

Middletown couple fight through lawsuits, zoning problems to open New Paltz cannabis dispensary

0:41
State budget proposal would consolidate Medicaid program used in hiring home health aide

State budget proposal would consolidate Medicaid program used in hiring home health aide

1:35
Double Up Food Bucks program comes to Yonkers market

Double Up Food Bucks program comes to Yonkers market

1:45
Surveillance video captures 58 water trucks in South Blooming Grove neighborhood in one month amid water crisis

Surveillance video captures 58 water trucks in South Blooming Grove neighborhood in one month amid water crisis

0:46
Schuyler Crossing management express frustration with ongoing flooding at affordable housing complex

Schuyler Crossing management express frustration with ongoing flooding at affordable housing complex

0:32
Out-of-court settlement reached in New Rochelle excessive force lawsuit

Out-of-court settlement reached in New Rochelle excessive force lawsuit

0:35
Legal battle over Harrison town supervisor election comes to an end

Legal battle over Harrison town supervisor election comes to an end

Vote 2024: Ask your questions for Congressional District 16 Democratic candidates

Vote 2024: Ask your questions for Congressional District 16 Democratic candidates

0:23
Ford recalls over 456,000 Bronco Sport and Maverick cars due to loss of drive power risk

Ford recalls over 456,000 Bronco Sport and Maverick cars due to loss of drive power risk

1:44
Discover a Gothic Revival masterpiece of art and architecture at Lyndhurst Mansion

Discover a Gothic Revival masterpiece of art and architecture at Lyndhurst Mansion

0:51
Save money while helping the planet with these 12 energy-efficient tips

Save money while helping the planet with these 12 energy-efficient tips