Murphy official accused of rape told to find new job, but wasn’t fired

An official in Gov. Phil Murphy’s administration was asked to find a new job, but wasn’t outright fired when he was accused of sexual assault

News 12 Staff

Dec 18, 2018, 11:46 PM

Updated 1,954 days ago

Share:

An official in Gov. Phil Murphy’s administration was asked to find a new job, but wasn’t outright fired when he was accused of sexual assault, according to testimony that came out during a legislative committee hearing Tuesday.
Murphy's chief of staff, Pete Cammarano, told a joint legislative panel Tuesday that he told Al Alvarez in March that he should leave the Schools Development Authority where he was a top aide.
When asked why he didn't fire Alvarez, Cammarano said he thought his message was clear.
“When the chief of staff tells you you need to look for employment outside of state government the message is clear and judging from his reaction at the time and his conversation back and forth, he understood what I was saying,” Cammarano said.
Cammarano also backed up Gov. Murphy's claims that he knew nothing about the allegations until reporters started asking questions in October. Cammarano said he was told state personnel policies meant he couldn't tell the governor anything.
“I was advised by two different lawyers at two different times that there were confidentiality requirements concerning the victim's allegations. To the best of my knowledge no one ever told the governor,” Cammarano testified.
Alvarez's former boss, Charlie McKenna, was appointed to the Schools Development Authority by former Gov. Chris Christie. McKenna testified that Murphy's chief attorney told him to instruct Alvarez to find another job in June. But McKenna says that when he left in August, Alvarez was still employed.
“Every governor's different but if the governor that I worked for, if I didn't tell him this, I would still be feeling the pain today,” McKenna said.
Alvarez resigned in October, when Katie Brennan detailed allegations of sexual assault to the Wall Street Journal. Brennan alleges that Alvarez sexually assaulted her in April 2017 when both were working to get Murphy elected. Alvarez denied wrongdoing.
Murphy's transition team was notified about the allegations against Alvarez about a month before Murphy took office.
Assemblywoman Nancy Munoz read a Dec. 3, 2017 transition team memo that laid out options for what the incoming Murphy administration should do with Alvarez. The email stated the administration could discuss the situation privately with Alvarez, keep him in the dark but monitor his actions, or do nothing at all and see how it played out.
The next committee hearing will be Jan. 8, 2019.
The Associated Press wire services contributed to this report.


More from News 12
1:49
Human remains unearthed during drainage work in Putnam County

Human remains unearthed during drainage work in Putnam County

0:56
Sunny for the rest of the workweek ahead before possible wet weekend in Hudson Valley

Sunny for the rest of the workweek ahead before possible wet weekend in Hudson Valley

2:07
Westchester County preps for President Joe Biden's visit

Westchester County preps for President Joe Biden's visit

1:53
Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

0:22
Police: 29-year-old man dies after burning incident at Warwick Park

Police: 29-year-old man dies after burning incident at Warwick Park

2:30
Biden campaign reports blockbuster fundraising hauls ahead of visit

Biden campaign reports blockbuster fundraising hauls ahead of visit

0:23
Westchester DA: Ex-Mamaroneck library employee stole over $40,000 from library

Westchester DA: Ex-Mamaroneck library employee stole over $40,000 from library

0:42
Yonkers Spano releases proposed budget for 2025

Yonkers Spano releases proposed budget for 2025

1:54
State budget excludes aid for Orange County storm victims, lawmakers criticize Gov. Hochul

State budget excludes aid for Orange County storm victims, lawmakers criticize Gov. Hochul

1:52
Final negotiations on Carmel schools' budget linger late into the night

Final negotiations on Carmel schools' budget linger late into the night

0:40
Hochul: $33 million allocated to mental health in the state budget to expand services for felons

Hochul: $33 million allocated to mental health in the state budget to expand services for felons

0:31
Yonkers official calls for protection of city’s war memorial from graffiti, vandalism

Yonkers official calls for protection of city’s war memorial from graffiti, vandalism

2:07
​Officials hope to implement noise cameras to combat loud noise from street racing in Greenburgh

​Officials hope to implement noise cameras to combat loud noise from street racing in Greenburgh

0:36
Police: Father pleads guilty to string of burglaries from 2022

Police: Father pleads guilty to string of burglaries from 2022

0:28
President Biden's visit prompts early dismissals in Westchester schools

President Biden's visit prompts early dismissals in Westchester schools

Vote 2024: Ask your questions for Congressional District 16 Democratic candidates

Vote 2024: Ask your questions for Congressional District 16 Democratic candidates

0:31
Mount St. Mary College welcomes new president

Mount St. Mary College welcomes new president

0:57
Airlines will now be required to give automatic cash refunds for canceled and delayed flights

Airlines will now be required to give automatic cash refunds for canceled and delayed flights

1:49
Proposal for Putnam County lithium-ion battery storage station raises concerns in Westchester

Proposal for Putnam County lithium-ion battery storage station raises concerns in Westchester

0:41
Fire destroys car, damages garage in Rhinebeck

Fire destroys car, damages garage in Rhinebeck