Croton Falls drowning victim identified as 73-year-old John Scales

Investigators aren't sure why a fishing boat capsized,

Investigators aren't sure why a fishing boat capsized, throwing two men into the Croton Falls Reservoir.

CROTON FALLS - One man is dead and another is recovering this morning after falling out of their fishing boat and into the Croton Falls Reservoir in Putnam County yesterday.

Officials say John Scales, 73, and Joe Gay Jr., 82, both of Manhattan, somehow fell out of the boat around 3 p.m. Gay was able to swim to the shoreline and talk to emergency crews when they arrived on the scene, telling them that Scales was down in the water. That set off a major search both by land and air, as police called in divers.

"Once the dive teams got here, we brought two divers out. We had two guys searching the water, searching the last known area of where the victim went down," says Croton Falls Fire Chief Jason Blauvelt.

Divers found Scales after he been in the water for about an hour, but attempts to revive him were not successful.

Meanwhile, Gay was taken to Putnam Hospital Center in Carmel. He has since been released.

The boat did not capsize as originally reported, but it is still unclear at this time what caused the fishermen to lose their balance and fall. Both men were in possession of personal flotation devices, but neither was wearing them.

The Department of Environmental Protection, which oversees the reservoir, continues to investigate the incident.

Fishing is permitted in reservoirs, and investigators say the pair had the proper permits.

advertisement | advertise on News 12

Trending Video

News 12 asked residents what they thought about 1 Westchester Talks Trump: First 100 days
Police say Kenya Reed witnessed Blair Robinson beat 2 Yonkers mother charged in connection to son's death
News 12 Interactive 3 News 12 Varsity Report for April 28
Extended interview with Greenpoint igloo creators 4 Extended interview with Greenpoint igloo creators
An elderly woman with Alzheimer's was found after 5 Missing elderly woman found safe

advertisement | advertise on News 12

More News

Officials say a man is dead after a Officials: Man dies after raft capsizes in Croton Falls Reservoir

Officials say a man is dead after a raft capsized during a fishing trip at

Sorry to interrupt...

Your first 5 are free

Access to News12 is free for Optimum, Comcast®, Time Warner® and Service Electric℠ video customers.

Please enjoy 5 complimentary views to articles, photos, and videos during the next 30 days.