Judge tosses plea deal for man accused of brutally beating neighbor

A judge tossed a plea deal Wednesday for a Milford man accused of a brutal attack on his neighbor who lives with multiple sclerosis.

News 12 Staff

Jan 22, 2020, 10:12 PM

Updated 1,548 days ago

Share:

A judge tossed a plea deal Wednesday for a Milford man accused of a brutal attack on his neighbor who lives with multiple sclerosis.
Prosecutor Chuck Stango said he's never seen a deal vacated at sentencing, but that's what the judge did after hearing the victim's impact statement.
Lori Wierzbicki walked out of the court with help from a cane and her brother -- no longer afraid her attacker could go free.
"I was going in with the attitude that it probably wasn't going to be good because I just didn't want to get my hopes up, but this is wonderful," said Wierzbicki.
The case against Russell Molleur is now back to square one. The plea deal he previously accepted is off the table.
Until Wednesday, Molleur was facing a maximum of two years with the chance for his attorney to argue for no additional time.
Wierzbicki was choked and beaten unconscious during a bloody attack in her home last March.
In court Wednesday, she told the judge her MS prevented her from fighting back. Though her physical injuries have healed, she deals with the emotional ones every day.
In his ruling, the judge pointed to Wierzbicki's MS and another pending case against Molleur. After court, Wierzbicki said she was grateful the judge listened to her victim's impact statement.
Tim McLaughlin has led the push to get justice for his sister. McLaughlin organized a rally and started an online petition against the plea deal. He brought a binder to court Wednesday with more than 19,000 signatures to show the judge.
"It feels good to not only have the support of the community and to have all this love, but also to have a victory within the walls of the courtroom," said McLaughlin.
Molleur's attorney told the judge her client is very sorry for what happened and has fully cooperated with the investigation. She said he needs to be in a living facility rather than jail because he has intellectual disabilities and is in reality like a child. She also said Molleur's life was fine until five years ago when his mother died and he turned to alcohol.


More from News 12
2:06
Lyndhurst in Bloom flower show is this weekend at Lyndhurst Mansion

Lyndhurst in Bloom flower show is this weekend at Lyndhurst Mansion

2:04
Dry afternoon for Friday throughout the Hudson Valley before evening showers roll in

Dry afternoon for Friday throughout the Hudson Valley before evening showers roll in

Kerhonkson man indicted for killing, dismembering girlfriend

Kerhonkson man indicted for killing, dismembering girlfriend

Vote 2024: Ask your questions for Congressional District 16 Democratic candidates

Vote 2024: Ask your questions for Congressional District 16 Democratic candidates

1:10
State police in the Hudson Valley ramp up patrols to catch impaired drivers on April 20

State police in the Hudson Valley ramp up patrols to catch impaired drivers on April 20

0:54
Protesters march outside Yonkers County Family Court to call for reform in the system

Protesters march outside Yonkers County Family Court to call for reform in the system

0:31
Greenwood Lake mayor, village building inspector suddenly resign

Greenwood Lake mayor, village building inspector suddenly resign

Middletown fairgrounds to host Burnout Nationals finale

Middletown fairgrounds to host Burnout Nationals finale

0:38
1 of 2 men charged in Bedford firebombing pleads guilty

1 of 2 men charged in Bedford firebombing pleads guilty

0:24
Holtec International sues NYS over law banning discharge of radiological waste into the Hudson

Holtec International sues NYS over law banning discharge of radiological waste into the Hudson

0:29
Cortlandt community composting program accepting food scraps

Cortlandt community composting program accepting food scraps

0:26
Rifton USPS in Ulster County closed indefinitely due to safety hazard

Rifton USPS in Ulster County closed indefinitely due to safety hazard

0:21
The Orange County Land Trust launches wilderness campaign effort

The Orange County Land Trust launches wilderness campaign effort

0:46
Westchester County’s Environmental Facilities hosted its 5th annual Eco Awards

Westchester County’s Environmental Facilities hosted its 5th annual Eco Awards

0:40
Authorities: Mahopac man captured sexually explicit images of children with hidden camera

Authorities: Mahopac man captured sexually explicit images of children with hidden camera

0:50
Bark Air is launching flights catered to dogs out of Westchester County Airport

Bark Air is launching flights catered to dogs out of Westchester County Airport

1:40
Preliminary report uncovers over 100 potential unmarked burials at historic Rye cemetery

Preliminary report uncovers over 100 potential unmarked burials at historic Rye cemetery

0:40
TEDx Talk at Mamaroneck HS focuses on mental health of adolescents, families, communities

TEDx Talk at Mamaroneck HS focuses on mental health of adolescents, families, communities

Is your mom awesome? Hudson Valley tell us why your Mom Rocks!

Is your mom awesome? Hudson Valley tell us why your Mom Rocks!

0:54
Guide: How to host Passover on a budget

Guide: How to host Passover on a budget